Bassam Tahhan Quotes
Let me remind you of a historical fact that is accepted by all. In the year 901 - an unfortunate year for Muslims - a Muslim qadi named Ibn Mujahid canonized one version of the Koran. Before that, there were many different versions of the Koran, and this did not upset the good Muslims!
Soon after individual inquiry and interpretation was discouraged and then made illegal and punished just as with the Christian Church at the time. Thereafter, the Islamic societies were intellectually closed and deteriorated resembling the Christian state of intellectuality. The Christians began to slowly liberalize and the Protestant Reformation spurred new thinking and Christianity was reinvented by both Catholics and Protestants and Christian intellectual, political, and economic development thrived. Islam has not yet had a reformation but there are modernist Muslims trying. See {623580} .
Bassam Tahhan, SyrIan born Islamic French Scholar of Arabic Literature, Islamic Modernist, Telquel (Morocco), Issue 229, June, 2006, Translated in “Muslim Intellectual Calls for ‘Protestant Islam” MEMRI, July 6, 2006
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
This is not terribly different however from Christians and Jews selectively quoting the Bible.
Turks and Arabs tend to blame each other for the stagnation of Islam.
In the Middle Ages, the Muslim World, was the leading scientific, philosophical, mathematical, medical, and historical center of the world. The intellectual decline of Islam has been striking and history has been no exception. The vast majority of 21st century Muslims have little or no idea of the past intellectual achievements of Islam.
She makes the critical point that in America, for the first time in history, Islam could develop “where the freedoms of thought and speech are guaranteed political rights.” The result she believes will be an Islamic Reformation. America and its freedoms has actually fostered the development and creation of many religions. For example, Christian Science, Reform Judaism, Pentecostalism, Mormonism are just a few. Even American Roman Catholicism has evolved some unique characteristics.
This was one of the sagest pieces advice regarding Islam given in the early 20th century.
Ibn al-Nafis was one of the great scientists of all time. He analyzed the human heart, lungs, and circulatory system. This quotation is often given by Muslim modernists and reformers to illustrate that Islam at one time was open to new knowledge, dissent, ideas of all kinds. A century later, Islam closed intellectually and later and even today, Muslims are killed for what became heresy. Truth became determined by the Koran and the words of The Prophet only, Christianity and the Church imposed a similar restrictive view of truth using the Bible and Jesus. However, the Reformation and modernity led Christianity to merge and adopt the more modern and scientific view with the exception of some Christian fundamentalists. Islam had the modern view and abandoned it causing the many educated Islamic reformers and modernists of today great difficulty in changing the culture and laws as a whole.
The major complaints of Muslim fundamentalists then was that “non believers” should never be in government positions of authority over Muslims and that Islamic Law—Sharia—was not the law of the land. The modern and reformist Muslims tried to change the vision of their co-religionists but progress was slow. Over a century later, the same complaints are made by Islamic fundamentalists today and the Muslim reformers are still trying to persuade them that what they want is not desirable.
The Hijra was the spread of Islam after The Prophet organized the first Muslims. Islamic reformers have been trying to improve the legal and cultural position of women in Islamic Societies ever since with little success, even in modern times. The notable exception was the Turkish Revolution led by Ataturk. He was familiar with Aga Kahn arguments for reform and put the force of law behind them. See {444998}.
Historically, this quotation shows that the negative relationship between the West and Islam and negative views of Islam was not a new phenomenon at the beginning of the 21st century. It existed long before, and as with the 21st century concerns, violence and war were the major concerns.
He was one of the first Islamic thinker to distinguish between the Koran and the requirements of Islam on the one hand and the traditions of the cultures of the Arabian Peninsula on the other. For example, there is no justification anywhere in Islamic theology for the “Honor Killing” of women; it was a long standing tradition of some of the cultures. But many Muslims and non-Muslims believe that the practice is a part of Islam. There are hundreds of other examples and Abduh tried to eradicate the influence of these traditions. He had traditional and extremist opponents in his lifetime as well as today.
This is another of De Tocqueville’s prescient statements that in retrospect seem so amazing given the time. This quotation could serve as an op ed in a newspaper of any of the industrial democracies of the early 21st century. However, he did not have the information of the details we have today that showed Islam as the pinnacle of scientific, philosophical, literary and medical achievement at the beginning of the second millennium, while the Christian nations of Europe were mired in the Dark Ages. It was the same Koran but a very different interpretation and framework that led to the decadence while it was the Protestant Reformation that triggered a Christianity that was hospitable to modernity and enlightenment.
Huqqani was specifically referring to Muslim religious scholars, but his point is more general and applies equally to some religious scholars and clerics of Christian, Jewish, Buddhist and other persuasions.
The prohibition of anything new has been one of the reasons for the decadence of Islam over the years. When originated, it was the most modern religion in the world. However as other religions grew and reformed, Islam has not and resists all new things. Christianity which was in the Dark Ages when Islam began, did change including the Protest Reformation so by the end of the 17th century the Christian world was more advanced scientifically, politically, and economically.
This verse has been one of the bases of Muslim theocratic states like Iran’s claim to legitimacy. The word “govern” is sometimes translated as “judge.” In the context of the 6th century, there were no separation of powers as we know them and judging, governing and legislating were melded.
This statement by The Prophet has been interpreted by Muhammad Abduh and other Islamic modernists and reformers as a call for co-existence and common ground between Muslims on the one hand and Christians and Jews on the other. However, some Muslim extremists interpret this sura to mean that the call is for the Christians and Jews to accept Islam and THEN there will be common words. There is in modern times, there is no Islamic Hierarchy like a Pope to make a definitive determination about such an interpretation so Muslims are split on the interpretation. In that sense Muslims today are like Protestants, Jews and Buddhists.
Bassam Tahhan is a Syrian-born French professor of Arabic literature and expert on the Quran. As of 2006 he taught at the Henri IV secondary school in Paris. Tahhan advocates a Protestant reformation in Islam. He defines a "Protestant Islam," as "Islam that allows freedom of thought and permits questioning the Sunna, abrogating hadiths not grounded in the Koran, and reinterpreting the Koran in light of modern values."