M. Raymond Poincare Quotes
France has no intention of holding the Ruhr permanently. She means to stay there until she is paid, or has assurances that she will be paid.... We intend to hold the mining and industrial basin until Germany fulfills its agreement…. Paralyzing the mining industry in the Ruhr may inflict hardships on France as well as Germany, but Germany is the greater loser and France will show the endurance necessary to outwit the German Government.
After WWI, the Germans were reluctant to make the reparation payments that they had agreed to in the peace treaty. The French, to “motivate” the Germans, occupied the German Ruhr Valley—an area that contained very important German heavy industry and coal mines that could not function under the occupation. See {640091}.
M. Raymond Poincare, 1860-1934, French President, Statement, January 29, 1923, Quoted in Nicholas Roosevelt, “The Ruhr Occupation”, Foreign Affairs, October 1925
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
After WWI, the Germans were reluctant to make the reparation payments that they had agreed to in the WWI peace treaty. The French, to “motivate” the Germans, occupied the German Ruhr Valley—an area that contained very important German heavy industry and coal mines that could not function under the occupation. See {640090}.
The Germans pretended to maintain the treaty and when the French totally evacuated the Rhineland, Hitler started his preparation for WWII and a little later invaded France. Clemenceau had been snookered.
1st Earl Lloyd-George of Dwyfor. Demands for German reparations were very popular with the British electorate at the end of World War I.
The Germans, having invaded France and other countries in WWI, were determined in the Treaty of Versailles to be responsible for the war. They were to pay reparations to France and other countries to cover the costs to those countries of financing the war and rebuilding what the German invasion destroyed. But Germany too was destitute and needed capital to rebuild and if they paid the reparations whey would have to lay a very heavy tax on all Germans and still would not have enough to rebuild their nation and economy. What made the situation much worse was the fact that most of the wealthy German capitalists—many of whom had profited from supplying military weapons and supplies during the war—took all their money out of Germany, so the wealthiest Germans could not be taxed much at all. Auld, and many others tried to find an equitable solution, but that never happened and German resentment carried over into WWII where the Germans again invaded France.
Hoover and most Republicans were generally opposed to sanctions and an instrument of foreign policy. 25 years after his presidency, the Republican Party started embracing sanctions as a tool of foreign policy and by the end of the 20th century, Republicans were sanction hawks. This quotation illustrates how American political parties and their philosophies change over time.
He was exactly right. Two decades later Germany had started WWII.
At the time there were UN sanctions against Iran for violating the Non Proliferation Treaty regarding transparency of its nuclear development.
Wilson had asked him to give more consideration to the German point of view in World War I peace negotiations.
The Germans wanted to make a deal with Britain to remain neutral while Germany attacked and conquered France’s colonies. In their view England and Germany would share the dominance of the world. The British would not sell out the French with whom they had a treaty, and WWI began.
Nicolson was an eyewitness to the proceedings.
This is an important historical quotation because it suggests some of the thinking, irrational though it may have been, that led many post war Germans onto an irrational and self defeating course of action. Emotional factors such as dignity, fairness, and honor can be significant drivers of irrational and self destructive action. Nazi Germany was a classic example. Many leading Germans thought the Treaty of Versailles that was imposed on them at the end of the First World War was too harsh and unfair. Many from the countries victimized by the German military aggression also thought the treaty unfair as it did not treat Germany harsh enough.
The railroads were nationalized for WWI and he ran them all as a government official. There have been political situations like this one where public opinion was so intense and extreme that any action that satisfied public opinion would have very negative aspects and/or be unrealistic or impossible while realistic solutions are unacceptable to public opinion. Usually, the reaction of the politicians is to punt and simply not deal with the issue or problem but claim that they are seeking a solution.
Poincare and his policy advisors thought that the Germans were bluffing as they had in the past. This time they were not. WWI followed.
A few months later, that is exactly what Germany did. She was hoping that England would not enter the war despite her treaty obligations, but she was willing to risk the possibility. The Czar had a strong espionage and intelligence service active in Germany, but, like so many other intelligence failures, the intelligence operatives and analysts had military and economic facts but had little understanding of the German culture which propelled Germany to what to most other cultures was “irrational policy making.” People and nations often engage in irrational activities, even against their own self-interest.
At the time France and Germany controlled different parts of the Ruhr Valley. Each believed that they should control it all and the other had no right to control any of it. This never did get settled and was one of the justifications Germany gave in WWII for invading the area. Haskins was one of only three assistants who were part of Woodrow Wilson’s team that negotiated the Treaty of Versailles ending WWI.
This was 6 years after the German defeat in WWI. That Dream helped propel Hitler to power and the German aggression of WWII.