Gamal Al-Banna Quotes


The lawsuits we are seeing today to ostracize and prevent different ideas recall previous eras. We must understand that Islam has given man freedom of thought. Islam's history proves that no one is immune to error except the Prophet.


Context

In 2005 an Egyptian writer, Usama Anwar Ukasha, criticized one of the Prophet’s companion’s role for causing dissention and divisiveness in Islamic history. Some called for his legal punishment for slandering a holy figure (see {588714}) and a law case was brought to force him to divorce his wife—so that she would not be “contaminated by his heretical thoughts. Al-Bana argued for freedom of thought and speech on such subjects. His view was particularly important since he was the brother of Hassan Al-Bana, the founder of the Muslim Brotherhood, a powerful fundamentalist organization. Note that Al-Bana’s call for intellectual freedom does not go so far as to say that it should be legal to criticize The Prophet Muhammad and it illustrates how far even modern Islam has to go to meet reasonable standards of freedom of thought and speech.


Citations

Gamal Al-Banna, Egyptian Intellectual

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Linked Quotes

Amr ibn Al-'Aas was one of the companions of the Prophet Muhammad. In 2005 an Egyptian writer, Usama Anwar Ukasha, criticized the companion’s role for causing dissention and divisiveness in Islamic history. Some called for his legal punishment for slandering a holy figure and a law case was brought to force him to divorce his wife—so that she would not be “contaminated” by his heretical thoughts. Some Egyptians argued that anyone should have the right to analyze and criticize the role of any historical figure—except for The Prophet (see {585045})—but Dr. Shahin explained that under Islamic Law (Sharia) such criticism may not be permitted and the state should punish the offender.


Related Quotes
No Photo Available
  • Born: December 15, 1920
  • Died: January 30, 2013
  • Nationality:
  • Profession:

Gamal al-Banna was an Egyptian author, and trade unionist. He was the youngest brother of Hassan al-Banna (1906–49), founder of the Muslim Brotherhood. Al-Banna was considered a liberal scholar, known for his criticism of Islamic traditional narratives rejecting 635 Hadiths of Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim which he finds contradictory to the Qur'an. He was a great-uncle of the Swiss Muslim academic and writer Tariq Ramadan.