Al-Musabbihi Quotes


The dai (famous professor) gave many lectures in the Palace, lecturing separately to the adepts, the members of the court, the common people and strangers. To women, he lectured in the Jam-i Azhar, where a separate chamber was allotted to the women of the court


Context

The Palace of Wisdom is said to be the first official non-religious academy or university in the Islamic World—it seems the Christian world as well. It taught the sciences including astronomy, logic, philosophy, mathematics, as well as history, theology, languages and medicine. Note that women were educated also, albeit separately. And this was under a Caliph who was a fundamentalist. This quotation is frequently used to demonstrate that the recent trend of some Islamic fundamentalism—the Taliban for example—toward keeping females in ignorance is not a Muslim tradition and has not traditionally been interpreted as a mandate of the religion until recently. Note that the same male “professors” who taught the men, also taught the women. So just as women could be in the presence of male close relatives, teachers were provided the same exception, unlike the interpretation of the Taliban and other fundamentalist Muslims who would not allow women to be taught be men if at all.


Citations

al-Musabbihi, ?-1029, Iraq Historian, Description of Education in the Palace of Wisdom

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

The importance of women in the Hamas, fundamentalist vision is to function as a brood mare to “manufacture” men and then to bring them up which at least requires something more than their bodies. The role of women in producing other women however is never mentioned as important.


Legal Religious Ruling. This is an example of a source of tension between some Muslims and others. Non-Muslims are required to have a Muslim Education in Muslim countries, but they insist that any required Christian or secular education in a non Muslim country is anti-Islamic.


Most Islamic fundamentalists oppose the education of girls. Malala Yousafzai as a teen ager spoke out encouraging girls to go to school. This offended some of the Taliban fundamentalist terrorist, who threatened her if she continued to speak out. When she continued, they tried to murder her. They shot her in the head, but she was airlifted for medical treatment and survived. She was the winner of the European Sakharov Prize for Freedom of Thought and nominated for the Nobel Prize.


Nowhere else in the world was there this large a number and density of sophisticated learning institutions. These colleges were midway between a college and a high school in the learning level and student ages of modern times.


This quotation is fascinating but sad. In 1902, Aga Kahn III and other Muslim reformers gathered to improve the terrible state of Muslim education. Muslims could attend the English operated public schools which were excellent, but the Imams fought these schools as they were purely secular and not under their control. Yet the Madrassas religious schools that then existed taught by rote and only Islamic religious content—no mathematics, science, other literature, art or anything else. Much of the teaching was religiously extreme with not even modern religious content. Over a century later the Schools of Pakistan—the Islamic nation carved out of India and those of most of the Arab nations are little better and despite a century of progress, the curriculum is the same.


This quote is significant for several reasons. First, it illustrates the theological dimension of the Saudi Arabian kingdom where the Royal Family maintains its position by always accommodating and financing the Wahabi fundamentalist version of Islam. Second, it shows how difficult it is for modern science to be taught and understood in fundamentalist Islamic societies. Third, it illustrates a historically classic repressive logic: He who disagrees with the current religious orthodoxy is disagreeing with the espousers of that religion. And if the espousers are wrong, they are lying. Therefore the dissenter is accusing God and his prophets of being liars. That is blasphemy and an insult to all believers. Last, it illustrates the parallel between Islam and Christianity in development. The latter is 700 years older than Islam, and about that long ago, the Roman Catholic Church repressed Galileo for claiming that the Earth was not the center of the universe.


Some Republicans were concerned about regulations requiring employers who provide health insurance to cover contraceptives could potentially interfere with their religious freedom if they had religious compunctions about birth control, but their proposed solutions would have denied some women in the work force basic medical care as recommended by almost all health authorities. Some of the strongest male opponents of the regulations had a long standing track record as being against birth control of any kind. Many women then rose up to protest what appeared to them as an attempt to roll back their hard won right to control their own body. The issue became a part of almost any discussion involving women, and advocates of providing all of women with birth control rights and availability showed how it tied in with almost every facet of a woman’s like. In this case, being able to go to and finish college and graduate school which becomes much less likely if a woman gives birth to an unplanned child.


Many of the Taliban leadership attended this Madrassa when young including Mullah Omar, the leader of the Taliban. Haq is often called “Father of the Taliban.”


He gave a litany of ills that have occurred when women had been educated. He did not provide any of the counter examples.


No Photo Available
  • Born:
  • Nationality:
  • Profession:

Al-Amīr al-Mukhtār ʿIzz al-Mulk Abū ʿAbd Allāh Muḥammad ibn Abiʾl Qāsim ʿUbayd Allāh ibn Aḥmad ibn Ismāʿīl ibn ʿAbd al-Azīz al-Ḥarranī al-Musabbiḥī al-Kātib, commonly known simply as al-Musabbihi (Arabic: المصبحي‎), was a Fatimid historian, writer and administrative official. He is known to have authored some 40,000 pages of manuscripts dealing with an array of topics, including history, psychology, law, grammar, sexology and cooking. Akhbār Miṣr, a contemporary chronicle of Egyptian history and news, was among al-Musabbihi's well-known works. However, like the vast majority of al-Musabbihi's works, only fragments of Akhbār Miṣr survived; most of his writings disappeared not long after his death.