Muhammed Shah Aga Kahn III Quotes
No country can ever flourish or make its mark as a nation, as long as the principle of (educational) compulsion is absent
In almost all societies until recent times, many uneducated people—especially from rural areas—were not enthusiastic about sending their children to school. They worried about losing the farm or factory labor of the children, losing control / influence, children learning unacceptable moral or religious ideas, and social mobility was so poor that many parents thought that it would never help the children.
Sultan Muhammed Shah Aga Khan III, 1877-1957, 48th Imam of the Shia Ismaili Moslems, President of the League of Nations, First president of the All-India Muslim League, Inaugural Speech at the All India Muhammadan Educational Conference, Delhi, India, December 4, 1911
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
At the time the Colonial British Government controlled the Indian Educational System. Kahn and a few others thought that the Indians should take control of their own educational systems.
It did not pass. Smalls had a hand in re-writing the Constitution of the State into which he had been born into slavery.
The Western style of education was extremely effective for the Hindus, but was much less successful for the Muslims. The result was that over time, the Hundus achieved success in the professions, civil service, arts and sciences while the Muslims did not, thus changing the then existing parity of the two groups. For more on the difficulty that the Muslims had with British public education, see {616919} & {616925}.
Jinnah’s vision was for a modern educational system and curriculum throughout Pakistan. He would not have recognized the religious madrassas that taught only the Koran and Islamic subjects that became so prevalent in Pakistan by the 21st century.
There are still some extreme conservatives who hold this view. To them and Mises, public education should not be allowed, much less required.
The phrase “national care and expense” was one that was seen as precedent for those advocating federal aid to education and a strong Department of Education. However, the majority of Adams contemporaries saw education, even public education, as a local matter. The word “education” or “school” never appeared in the Constitution. Adams was well before his time on this point.
His hope that the elite intelligentsia would lead the nation was thwarted by Islamic fundamentalism which destroyed most of Pakistan education by only teaching religion in its Madrassas and not allowing the leadership to have compulsory education. There has been an enormous brain drain with a huge number of the Pakistani intelligentsia on which Jinnah pinned his hopes, had no opportunity in Pakistan and emigrated to the United Kingdom and America.
Traditional Islamic education of the time only dealt with the Koran but the skills of modern life, medicine, law, science were taught in the British secular schools, which Muslims generally would not attend. Kahn urged all is fellow Muslims to benefit from all forms of education.
There were many opponents to compulsory education especially in the South and rural areas.