Simon Schama Quotes
It was the Sephardi Jews who brought fish and chips to Britain, actually, believe it or not, from the Mediterranean world. Apart from actually eating and selling fish and chips, they were kind of debt enforcers.
Schama, Simon. Interview. NPR, National Public Radio, 2013.
This was true in 1936 for almost all Jewish immigrants. Reform Judaism was actually started and developed in the United States to blend the Jewish assimilation to modern America with the philosophy and values of Judaism. Most American Jews gravitated to the Reform communities and synagogues. However starting in the 1950’s there were some ultra-orthodox Jewish groups who began to preach against assimilation. To them, the greatness of America was that they did not have to Assimilate. Like the Amish and a few other religious groups they could maintain their oldest traditions and be protected and tolerated by America. These were and are a minority of Jewish Americans. However in the late 20th century many orthodox and the “Conservative Branch” of Judaism in America began to be concerned that the result of Jewish assail;ration and the reduction of anti-Semitism was an increase in religious intermarriage of American Jews. They worried that the Jewish community will diminish over time to a much smaller minority. So they have instituted programs to limit Jewish assimilation to diminish intern,marriage. The majority of Jews however continue as Goldie Corash Michelson descriptor in 1936.
This quotation has great historical significance for its logic and perception as much as for its content, The Jewish population that the British admitted plus those already in Israel was a small fraction of the Arab population then and a tiny proportion of the Jews and Arabs now inhabiting Israel with a very high standard of living. This included over 1 million Russian Jewish immigrants, The perception of the capacity of land to support a population has always been underestimated, The Arabs simply extrapolated assuming no modernization, no technology, and every family having a small farm. Given Arab traditional perceptions of societal development, modern Israel could not possibly function, much less thrive as it does. This is one of the reasons that the Arab nations have been so reluctant to absorb more Palestinian Arab refugees. A backward view of society and assumption that the Arab status quo was then the optimum society prohibited the Arabs from modern developmental possibilities.
A boatload of 23 Jews had arrived in New Amsterdam in 1654 from a failed colony in Brazil. Governor Peter Stuyvesant, an anti-Semite, wanted to deport them and asked for permission from his superiors at the Dutch West India Company. The Directors of the company wanted good citizens in their colony, and the Jews had been very productive citizens in Amsterdam. The Governor was distressed and took this as a rebuke which it was. Stuyvesant was not a very good governor eaith from the point of view of the colomists or the company.
Because of the classic historical anti-Semitism and discrimination, Jews were barred from land ownership and as a result few were farmers or had agricultural experience in their families. They were tradesmen, artisans, professionals in Europe. So amongst Jews and non Jews alike the notion of Jews settling the land of Palestine and farming it or trapping, the way the Boers had in South Africa or the French in Canada, was not a very credible image. The Zionists, realizing this potential weakness, placed strong emphasis on agriculture, developed the agricultural kibbutz concept and encouraged Jews to become farmers. The effort was so successful that almost all the leading early Zionist immigrants to Palestine became farmers. When independence came to Israel, the Jewish agriculture was more productive than most of that in Europe and almost on a par with small farms in the United States. The Israelis were known for “making the desert bloom.
The advocacy of the Jewish Return to the Holy Land was not first suggested or stated by European Jewish Zionists. Brightman was not only the first Christian to urge the return of the Jews, but the secon person of any faith to suggest it. He was only preceded by a Jewish refugee from the Spanish Inquisition--Joseph Nasi in 1561.
Ireland was then under English Control but the majority of the population were Roman Catholic. The Protestants wanted to bring more “balance” to the country. They were so anxious to dilute the Catholic population that they considered Jews as Protestants for this purpose and many of them immigrating to Dublin created the foundation of the Irish Jewish population in modern Ireland.
Some Palestinians and other Arabs either ignore or are delusional about history as the Jews had been in the Area for 5 thousand years, and when Christ was born and died and Christianity born, the Jews were the majority population in the area of Israel and Palestine. Even in the Muslim Controlled Ottoman Empire, Jews were living in the area and are described on thousands of Ottoman legal and historical documents. The reason that this quotation is so important is that Abbas was supposed to be the most reasonable of the Arab leaders regarding a two state solution, and here in 2014 he argued that the Jews to not belong in the area and have no roots there. The other Hamas Arab leaders required in their charter the destruction of Israel and the death of all Jews anywhere in the world. Who then, many conservative Israelis ask, can Israel reasonably negotiate with as no state will negotiate for its own existence—especially the most democratic, most developed, and has the highest average standard of living for its citizens and the most freedom for Arabs of any nation in the Middle East.
Sir Simon Michael Schama CBE FBA FRSL is an English historian specialising in art history, Dutch history, Jewish history and French history. He is a University Professor of History and Art History at Columbia University, New York.