Lyman Abbott Quotes


Society exempts woman from police functions. She is not called to be sheriff or constable or night watchman. She bears no truncheon and wears no revolver. She answers not to the summons when peace officers call for the posse comitatus. She is not received into the National Guard when bloody riot fills the city with peril and alarms. Why not? Is she not the equal of man? Is she not as loyal? as law abiding ? as patriotic? as brave? Surely. All of these is she. But it is not her function to protect the state when foreign foes attack it; it is the function of the state to protect her. It is not her function to protect the persons and property of the community against riot; it is man's function to protect her. Here at least the functional difference between the sexes is too plain to be denied, doubted, or ignored. Here at least no man or woman from the claims of equality of character jumps to the illogical conclusion that there is an identity of function.


Context

Without realizing it Abbott conceded some of the reasons that some people opposed women serving in the military. His entire argument hangs on the slender thread that it is not the function of a woman which was a view held by some people with particular religious and philosophical views. When that group was clearly shown to be a minority of Americans, women entered military service and joined police forces across the country.


Citations

Lyman Abbott, 1835–1922, Congregationalist theologian, editor, and author, “Why Women Do Not Want The Suffrage”, The Atlantic Monthly, September 1903

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Linked Quotes

This illustrates some of the illogic of some of the opponents of female suffrage. The fear was so great, that the very thought of woman voting along with men becomes in his mind, women controlling the electoral process. Since women voted in America sometimes they have made the difference in an election and sometimes it was the men—most often it was neither as a bloc. Also, it never occurred to Abbot that women could possibly enforce the laws along with men or fight in the military if the voters decide on war. See {629405} for his rigid view. A logical fallacy of Abbot’s argument is that the same thing can be said of old men. If the decisions of the voters need enforcement or military action, the older men of the society will not be the ones to enforce the laws or fight in the wars. So according to Abbot’s defective logic, the older (or disabled) men should not be allowed to vote when they reach the stage in life that they can no longer fight in war or serve as a policeman.


Related Quotes
Lyman Abbott
Lyman Abbott
  • Born: December 18, 1835
  • Died: October 22, 1922
  • Nationality: American
  • Profession: Theologian, Pastor (Protestant), Editor, Author

Lyman J. Abbott was an American Congregationalist theologian, editor, and author.