Aaron Belkin Quotes
Even military regimes must protect themselves from their own forces.
Aaron Belkin, Political Scientist, Founder and Director of the Center for the Study of Sexual Minorities in the Military, “United We Stand? Divide-and-Conquer Politics and the Logic of International Hostility,” State University of New York Press, 2005, Political Science Quarterly, Winter 2005-2006
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
Washington, though a military officer at the time, was very concerned with protecting the rights of citizens from abuse by the military for he had seen much of the abuse. The third amendment for example was later written to protect people from the military. The Constitution also requires that Congress make such rules for the military. Note that Washington, our first senior military officer at the time, wanted Congress to make detailed rules for the conduct of soldiers. In the 20th and 21st century, as the imperial presidency developed, there was a political view that only the military officers and the Commander in Chief should make the rules and regulations for the soldiers. However, there was no question but that the Founding Fathers saw this as a legislative branch function. Congress and Presidents have contested for this power every since.
The irony is that it is just for the lack of this fundamental principle that Napoleon eventually became the Government and the Military in France.
His statement was on the issuance of Executive Order 9981 which outlawed military segregation and granted equal treatment and opportunity to all service members regardless of their race:
There was a fear of standing armies in early America that lasted to some extent until the 20th century.
He was convicted as a War Criminal, sentenced to death, and then his sentence was commuted to life imprisonment. His quote is important because this was the defense that was totally rejected by the Nuremberg Tribunal—a solder is not required to obey an order to commit a war crime and if he does, he is as guilty as the person who gave the order.
He lost the vote on this issue, and the Congress created the first committee to investigate and oversee military affairs.
If a military loses a war, it has shown to be insufficient quality; if it wins, the evaluation is good. With all the talk about what makes for an effective and quality military, as the General states, it is war that is the final arbitrator. So ideally we never want to really know how good our military is.
There is frequently a disagreement between the military and civilian leaders just as there are disagreements among most political personnel. Hawks, and people who have had experience in the military tend to think that military advice on military matters should be determinative with the President and Congress. Others tend to believe that military advice should be considered, but if it were always adhered to, there would be no point in having civilian control over the military. See {639667} for an example of when military leadership advice prevailed and it was a mistake.
Aaron Belkin is a political scientist, researcher and professor. He currently teaches Political Science at San Francisco State University and is the director of the Palm Center, a think tank that commissions and disseminates research on gender, sexuality and the military.