Henry B.F. Macfarland Quotes


Even a President like Mr. McKinley, who has more personal friends than any other man in his party, cannot know who should fill every office to which he must make an appointment, even if he were disposed, as President McKinley was not, to ignore any of the party leaders. But President McKinley has held to one rule throughout his dealings with the party leaders in making appointments, and that is that he must have a suitable man for every vacancy. When a suitable man was not presented, the party leader would be given, politely but positively, the alternative of endorsing a man that the President could find without his assistance.


Context

His role was the equivalent of the Mayor of Washington DC. This quotation is historically important as it shows is the norms for appointments in this era. The local party leaders essentially had the privilege of selecting an appointee provided he was reasonable qualified. Where not he did appoint a few Democrats.


Citations

Henry B.F. Macfarland, 1861-*, Chairman of the Commissioners of the District of Columbia, Republican Friend and Supporter of William McKinley Jr, “Mr. McKinley as President”, The Atlantic Monthly, March 1901

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

Note that early constitutional experts assumed that one of the President’s roles was to be non partisan and control partisanship. Note the phrase ‘prevent the artifices of party’. The early founders were very wary of political parties of ‘factions’ as Madison called them. However, most were extremely partisan although in the Presidency partisanship was toned down by George Washington but after him, partisan ship became the norm.


Senator Conkling was the Republican Leader of the Republican Party and a party boss of the old school. Hays was a reformer, especially about appointments where he generally tried to pick the most meritorious candidate instead of the party loyalists desired by Conkling. There was (and still is) a tradition in the Senate that the Senators from the state of residence of any Presidential appointment had a veto of any Federal appointments in the state. Conkling, in addition to being the party leader, was the senior senator from New York and wanted two party loyalists for the jobs. Hayes appointed the better qualified men and decided to fight for the nomination of his candidates, but expected tha Conkling was strong enough to assure that the Senate would not confirm Hayes’ New York appointments. See {622341} for the outcome.


This quotation is valuable because it illustrates the classic implementation of the political spoils system before there was civil service with a merit system. This was not only typical of how people get government jobs, but it was the virtually the only way. In the language of the day, this letter from the Governor to a major political boss says: “Give this fellow a job. He is a loyal party man. Don’t give him a good job—a minor job will do, He is not that important.”


No Photo Available
  • Born:
  • Nationality:
  • Profession: