Sue Tucker Quotes


As a revenue raiser, gambling defies every principle. It’s regressive—it takes far more money out of poor people’s pockets than it does for higher income [people]. It’s cannibalistic—it eats other forms of revenue—when you have your citizens dumping $2 billion down the slots [slot machines], they’re not buying a car, and you lose that tax.


Context

She was one of the leaders fighting the proposal to allow casino gambling in the state. Months later, the legislature passed a bill allowing 3 casinos in the state and the Governor signed it. No one disagreed with Ms. Tucker, but with the Great Recession diminishing state tax revenue, most legislators and the governor felt that the benefits outweighed the problems.


Citations

Sue Tucker, Massachusetts State Representative & Senator (Democrat), CBS on NBC, 60 Minutes, August 2013

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

Samuel Langhorne Clemens, 1835-1910. The differential damage to the poor of lotteries was well known in the 19th century but the desire for money of governments, non-profit organizations, and corporations who administer many of the lotteries, blunted attempts to outlaw public lotteries. By the 21st century U. S. State Governments ran the largest lotteries in the world with the same differential detriment to the poor that Twain had described herein.


The Laffer curve was a mathematical, economic curve supposedly showing the relationship between tax rate and government revenue from taxes. In Laffer’s version of this curve, as interest rates go down, revenue from taxes goes UP because according to Laffer, there will be much more economic activity if taxes are lowered. In reality this has happened rarely in certain countries and in a very narrow range of tax deduction. As Chretien observes if you lower the tax rate to zero according to the Laffer curve this should maximize revenue but obviously it does not because with a zero rate there are no taxes collected even if the economy is booming. The Laffer curve was ideologically popular with those politicians wanting to lower taxes, but it never stood up to serious analysis and never worked in practice as Chretien observes. As a result, some people refer to the curve as the Laughter curve.


An income tax had been instituted during the Civil War but had lapsed. Existing taxes were all excise or head taxes—very regressive. Later there was a political movement to bring back the income tax with the intention of taxing all income equally. There was a titanic struggle which culminated in a Constitutional Amendment allowing the income tax. None of the original politicians, for or against, the income tax could never imagine an income tax that would charge lower rates for investment income. That was the entire purpose of the income tax at the beginning—to tax investment (unearned) income. The “capital gains tax” was the creative way of the rich getting back some of what they thought the lost when the income tax was instituted.


No Photo Available
  • Born:
  • Nationality:
  • Profession: