David Kiirkpatrick Quotes


With the present state of the Egyptian judiciary, they [the government] can convict anybody of anything.


Context

He had been reporting from Egypt at the time. There was no judicial independence, and the judges were generally corrupt and incompetent. The system operated as a tradeoff. The government would not investigate and punish the corruption and bribery in the private cases if the judges would always rule for the government in the cases they brought. The system was particularly pernicious in that Egypt did not depend on the jury of peers system so the judges had great power in judicial proceedings.


Citations

David Kiirkpatrick, Author & Journalist, Interview, PBS The Charlie Rose Show, July 2, 2014

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

At the time, it was relatively easy to find some sympathetic judge who saw labor unions as a menace, to issue an injunction forbidding a strike. It would take weeks, months and often years in those days to get to higher courts for appeals so this was a common strike breaking technique. That was the immediate stimulus for the statement. However it has been true generally. Almost all tyrannies operate under the cloak and authority of a judiciary and legal system which they control or is intimidated. 25 years after this quotation the world would see the worst example when the German judiciary supported and found legal all the Nazi excesses including the holocaust.


The government of Pakistan regarded this as seditious. The Government can fire judges at will and the military has the right to convene its own courts and try Pakistani civilians for certain alleged crimes by removing their cases from the civilian courts. Even when a Pakistani judge is not intimidated by the government or the military, the Islamic extremist fanatics often assassinate any public official who any one of thousands of fanatics feels is anti-Islamic.


Chase a Supreme Court justice at the time was a very partisan Federalist. The Senate was controlled by the Democratic Republicans. Randolph, then a member of the House of Representatives, orchestrated the impeachment of Chase because of his extreme partisanship. The Senate in trying the case had to decide for the first time what “high crimes and misdemeanors” the actually means in terms of impeachment. A number of the Democratic Republicans joined the Federalists in taking the view that however undesirable the Supreme Court justice’s partisanship would be, that did not reach the threshold of a “high crime and misdemeanor.” Chase was acquitted. In this sense this impeachment trial was similar to that of President William Clinton almost 200 years later. The behavior was undesirable but did not amount to a high crime and misdemeanor, Clinton was also acquitted.


This shameful quotation was shocking to most readers. It is subject to two interpretations: One that judges who did not rule on Constitutional issues the way conservative extremists wanted would come to physical harm. The other, that conservatives should pressure judges by withholding appropriations for the courts, impeachments and recall elections where they exist, as well as funding potential opponents for those jurisdictions where judges are elected. Both meanings were disgraceful in the view of most Americans. Later, DeLay was convicted and sentenced to jail for money laundering and illegally spending and raising campaign funds. He was also reprimanded by the House Ethics Committee for unethical methods of fund raising for other earlier actions.


Critics ask, “If legal authorities are so corrupted by making others suffer, why do they continue to do it, and why so much official corruption? Mises never provided an answer to this dilemma.


No Photo Available
  • Born:
  • Nationality:
  • Profession: