Lillian Smith Quotes


We in America – and men across the earth – have trapped ourselves with that word equality, which is inapplicable to the genus man. I wish we would forget it. Stop its use in our country: Let the communists have it. It isn’t fit for men who fling their dreams across the skies. It is fit only for a leveling down of mankind.


Context

She was one of the first prominent white Southerners to denounce racial segregation. However, her view was the “equality” argument just made the Southern whites more recalcitrant. Many white Southerners were willing to end segregation as it was un Christian and unfair, but were not willing to give up the image that they were superior. Others argued that unless they did give up the notion, segregation could never be ended.


Citations

Lillian Smith, 1897-1966, Writer, Reformer, & Political Activist, "Killers of the Dream", 1949

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

Marcus Porcius Cato. This quotation has had two different interpretations over time. One was that women if they received equality of treatment and voting would have an advantage for they also had their traditional “feminine wiles” and their sexuality, hence would dominate men. The second was a also a warning but based on the fact that women were superior in many ways, and given an equal chance, would excel men. The later interpretation is argued by some who point to the 2011 American data that shows more females than males graduating from high school and college, and females outnumber males in medical, law and several other professional schools. With the exception of a few Roman men, most heeded Cato’s warning and never took a chance on female equality.


In one of the earliest claims that women should be allowed to preach, she made a theological argument and then challenged the male theologians to better her arguments. Although she was very demur, intellectually and theologically she “took it right at them.” Such intellectual aggression by women was virtually unheard of.


The President often referred to this statement as an example of his wife’s acumen. She had been born to a Southern plantation and inherited the land and the slaves. Her view, and his, were typical of the Southern point of view in early America.


Lillian Smith
Lillian Smith
  • Born: December 12, 1897
  • Died: September 28, 1966
  • Nationality: American
  • Profession: Writer

Lillian Eugenia Smith was a writer and social critic of the Southern United States, known most prominently for her best-selling novel Strange Fruit (1944). A white woman who openly embraced controversial positions on matters of race and gender equality, she was a southern liberal unafraid to criticize segregation and work toward the dismantling of Jim Crow laws, at a time when such actions virtually guaranteed social ostracism.