Roy Asa Haynes Quotes


Prohibition is the greatest effort for human advancement and betterment ever attempted in history


Citations

Roy Asa Haynes, 1881-*, United States Commissioner of Prohibition, Speech, Women's Christian Temperance Union, January 26, 1927

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

Before we had national prohibition, many Southern states and counties outlawed alcohol. “Wets” were those who wanted to allow drinking of alcohol. “Drys” were those who did not. The South was “dry” and voted overwhelmingly for national prohibition, and later voted to keep it even when a majority of the country voted to repeal it. The irony was that the South has always been, and still is, one of the highest alcohol consumption regions and has had much alcoholism. Hence Roger’s humor.


A priest, Father Mathew, had been recommended for a State pension because of his extensive work of promoting temperance. However, his message played to and increased the degree of superstition, He preached that there were literal demons who would take over people and cause them to drink. The Queen was very aware of the symbolic value that every act of the crown conveyed and she was concerned about two things. First that superstition which she and most educated and enlightened people wanted diminished in society. Second, that the crown and the government would lose rational and scientific credibility so that future information and advice might be discounted by a cynical public who remember the crown arguing that demons were the cause of drinking and other ills. The same problem faces modern governments often. For example, in the middle of the 20th century, the Federal Government issued a film, Reefer Madness, which showed supposedly what happened when a person smoked marijuana. A few minutes after a young man smokes a marijuana cigarette, he starts to attack and rape a young woman at the party. The intent was to discourage people from smoking marijuana. But the consequences depicted were mostly false and to people who had smoked marijuana or observed smoking, the government appeared to be ignorant and or lying, The film became an icon of anti-government distrust and tendency to propaganda. Half a century later, the National Institutes of Health had trouble getting the true scientific facts about drug use believed as cynics still pointed to (and replayed on the Internet) Reefer Madness to show the government untrustworthy. Victoria understood this and took a long term view of the integrity and credibility of the crown and government.


The authenticity of this quotation has been in contention for years. While many sources attributed this statement to Lincoln, no one has ever found a document in which it appears. Further, it was so clearly consonant with the anti-Prohibition argument that we suspected it as a “Phantom Quotation” (See http://politicalquotes.org/node/4063). As a result, we did not include this quotation until March of 2014. The reason we changed our mind was a newspaper article that was pointed out to us, and after reading it, we tilted in favor of inclusion. The article is http://druglibrary.org/schaffer/LincolnQuote/lpq0001.jpg


Roy Asa Haynes
Roy Asa Haynes
  • Born:
  • Nationality:
  • Profession:

Roy Asa Haynes (1881–1940) was United States Assistant Secretary of the Treasury in charge of Prohibition enforcement from 1920–1925. He was succeeded by political appointee Lincoln Clark Andrews, who reorganized the enforcement bureau. He was the editor of a daily newspaper in Hillsboro, Ohio. Haynes was appointed by Warren Harding and considered a puppet of the Anti-Saloon League.