Vartan Gregorian Quotes
During this period the Arab world became an intellectual center for science, philosophy, medicine and education; the Abbasids championed the cause of knowledge and established the House of Wisdom (Bait-ul-Hikmat) at Baghdad, where both Muslim and non-Muslim scholars sought to translate and gather all the world's knowledge into Arabic. The Arabs displayed a remarkable capacity of assimilating the scientific knowledge of the civilizations they had overrun. Many classic works of antiquity that might otherwise have been lost were translated into Arabic and Persian and later in turn translated into Turkish, Hebrew and Latin. During this period the Arab world was a collection of cultures which put together, synthesized and significantly advanced the knowledge gained from the ancient Roman, Chinese, Indian, Persian, Egyptian, Greek, Byzantine and Phoenician civilizations.
8th to the 13th centuries This is known as the “Golden Age of Islam”. This is a very important historical quotation in that it gives us a picture of a world where modernity meant Islam, and Christianity was the epitome of backwardness.
Vartan Gregorian, Islam: A Mosaic, Not a Monolith, Cited in Wikipedia, 2003
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
This quotation is very instructive given the context. Christian Crusaders had wrested control of much of the Holy Land from the Muslims and established various local Christian Kingdoms and many had their own local king who was the equivalent of a war lord. Munqidh’s sons, his brother and their families were sailing to meet him and they even had a document of safe passage from the senior Christian King. Their ship developed trouble and they landed on the shores of the Christian mini kingdom. Instead of helping distressed vessels, the king and his men looted the ship taking all of value. They even took axes to the wood and carted that off to be sold for construction. However, they destroyed the books. This tells us: 1) It was not uncommon for Muslim nobles of no great power or prestige to have very large libraries. 2) These books were very highly valued by their Muslim owners. 3) That the Christian King and his minions were so ignorant that they did not even bother to steal the books, which could have been sold for more money than the rest of the ship and its content. These three conclusions support much other historical data to show that Islam was at that time a highly sophisticated, learned society, where philosophy, science, mathematics, medicine, literature all thrived and a substantial number of the books were the works of the great Greek scholars and scientists which were preserved by the Muslims when the nobles of Christian Europe most of whom were illiterate had lost the documentation of Western civilization. Unfortunately for Islam and the rest of the world, at about this time, Islamic clerics were calling for restrictions and a “closing” of Islamic society as it had become too free thinking with too many new ideas and discoveries being made, most of which were not mentioned in the Koran. In less than two centuries, Islamic scholarship and science had been reduced to a shadow of what it was. Scholars took their lives in their hands by introducing any know knowledge or ideas. Islam intellectually declined and fortunately many of the books were transported to Europe by Christians and Jews who were welcome collaborators with Islamic counterparts but no longer welcome. Italian medicine thrived and became famous when Jews came to Italy with the medical skills and literature that they had gleaned in the Muslim World. Europeans were gradually reintroduced to ancient Greek sciences and philosophy and literature. Despite the blockage of the Catholic Church (and later the Protestants) knowledge grew and spread in Europe and stultified in the Islamic lands. With the Christian world progressing and Islam intellectually regressing, the stage was set for the enlightenment and the dominance of the west and the minimal importance of Islam in the world of new ideas and scholarship.
This was a radical speech for the time, suggesting reforms that had been unthinkable to most Turks. Although it is not prohibited by the Koran and early Islamic artists made some of the greatest paintings and depictions of people, fundamentalists gained control of Islam and interpreted any statue as an idol that could be worshipped and this generalized to Islamic art in general where people ceased to be depicted and even animal depictions were rare. Muslim art developed incredible geometric intricacy but tended not to depict anything that is real. This extended to photography and illustrations in books including textbooks. At the same time, not unlike some Christian and Jewish Fundamentalists, the Muslim fundamentalists opposed science and the teaching thereof on the grounds that all authentic knowledge was in the Koran and anything else was not only false but also heretical. So this speech was a type of “declaration of war” against the established religious order and culture.
While most did not believe this at the time, it has come to pass that Russia first, and then China and India have developed an educated, competent workforce, that is very competitive to our own. This speech was given in the early days of WWII when it was far from clear that we would win.
This quotation is fascinating but sad. In 1902, Aga Kahn III and other Muslim reformers gathered to improve the terrible state of Muslim education. Muslims could attend the English operated public schools which were excellent, but the Imams fought these schools as they were purely secular and not under their control. Yet the Madrassas religious schools that then existed taught by rote and only Islamic religious content—no mathematics, science, other literature, art or anything else. Much of the teaching was religiously extreme with not even modern religious content. Over a century later the Schools of Pakistan—the Islamic nation carved out of India and those of most of the Arab nations are little better and despite a century of progress, the curriculum is the same.
Professor Lewis is the world’s leading expert on the Arab Islamic world.
During this period—especially the first 500 years, the Islamic world was far ahead of the Christian intellectually and culturally. A university in Bagdad actually had women students as well as men. Ironically, the Muslims studied and preserved the ancient Greek and Roman science and literature while the West slipped into the Dark Ages. The Muslims developed science and the arts to new heights. However, around 1100 a religious orthodoxy began to take hold that saw new innovation of any kind as blasphemous. Intellectually, Islamic society began to decline while at the same time the Christian world was emerging from the dark ages. After the Protestant reformation, Christendom intellectually began to thrive while Islam continued in its anti-intellectual and intolerant mode which still prevents most Muslim nations from modernizing, Note that there was American intellectual interest in Islam towards the end if the 19th century,
In 1453 the Ottoman Turks shocked Christendom by capturing Constantinople, the capital of the Byzantine Eastern Christian Empire. It was always perceived as a religious conflict between Christians and Muslims but that is an over simplification of a very complex sociological, religious, and political historical period. As this quotation shows us there were many Christians aiding the Muslim side. There were also many Muslims fighting on the Christian side.
This quotation makes it very difficult for Muslim modernists and reformers to persuade Muslims to adopt ideas, methods and approaches of the West, or China or India as this statement of the Prophet is a de facto stricture and inhibition against imitation of non-Muslims in any area.
This principle characterized most Islamic cultures for the next 400 years while Christian Europe was in the Dark Ages and had ignored most of the accumulated Western knowledge of the Greeks and Romans, The Muslims however, kept this knowledge alive and added to it supporting great mathematicians, scientists, philosophers, theologians and physicians. During the 12th century extreme fundamentalists gained control over Islam and this great principle of Umar’s was not only ignored but those who acquired new knowledge were persecuted as “innovators” often a capital crime. When Christian Europe began to rise intellectually, the Muslim societies were declining. Even today, the Islamic cultures are split as to the value of new knowledge and while there are modern Muslim scholars and scientists, there are still major forces throughout Islam who consider knowledge that is not in the Koran or which contradicts the Koran not only false, but heretical, often to be punished even by death.
He had a great deal of respect for the views of scholars and people who had little self or vested interest.
He is often called the “Father of Algebra” as the first person who actually wrote instructions for algebraic processes. At the time, Western mathematics was totally stagnant and intellectual development stifled by the Dark Ages and the Church.
This Quatrain amazingly preceded Tennyson’s expression of the same idea by almost 1000 years. See {620306}. At the time this was written Islam was entering the flower of its intellectual height where one could express doubt and be a religious dissident and not be murdered or even censored in many Muslim communities. At that time Islamic science, mathematics, philosophy, and literature was well in advance of Christian Europe. However, a hundred years later, the Islamic world went through a “Closing” where all new ideas became suspect and the religion and culture became stultified and Europe advanced while the Islamic world ceased its creative intellectual development.
“Mussalman” was another name for a Muslim. Jinnah was arguing for a separate Muslim state within India. 7 years later he got is wish and Pakistan was born. However many Muslims chose to remain in India even though it was a majority Hindu state. Jinnah was right for many Muslims and wrong for many others who have integrated into Indian society and there is some intermarriage in India, which has 120 million Muslims, almost as many as Pakistan with 160 million.
The Islamic leadership of that era came from the East and not Arabia. Theirs was a much more modern form of Islam where the basic values were very similar to those of other major religions. Also, toleration of minorities was an assumed requirement for all. When the axis of world Islamic leadership shifted to the Arab nations, the fundamentalist intolerance ascended and minorities were not only persecuted but were expelled from Arab countries in an effective ethnic cleansing. “Mussalman” was a then common word used in India to denote a Muslim.
Vartan Gregorian was an Armenian-American academic, educator, and historian. He served as president of the Carnegie Corporation from 1997 to 2021.