Victoria Roberts Quotes


Upholding ... suspicionless drug testing would set a dangerous precedent.


Context

The state of Michigan was trying to require adult welfare recipients to undergo random drug testing while adults not on welfare had the Constitutional right to be tested only if there was some reason to suspect them. See for a reaction to the case.


Citations

Victoria Roberts, Federal Judge, Decision Against the State of Michigan which wanted to do random drug testing of welfare recipients, September 2000

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

The state of Michigan was trying to require adult welfare recipients to undergo random drug testing while adults not on welfare had the Constitutional right to be tested only if there was some reason to suspect them. See #.


He was then a Senator. When he became Attorney General he not only greatly increased the amount of surveillance that was done be the Federal government, but he also asked for huge increases in government authority to read mail and conduct surveillance—increases that he had opposed when he was a Senator.


Actually it was Thomas Jefferson who had drafted most of the language. This attack was aimed at President John Adams, the big supporter of the unpopular Alien and Sedition laws, and the man Jefferson was intent on unseating at the end of his first term. He did and destroyed the Federalist Party in the process.


Johnson, fundamentally an inveterate racist, tried to kill all attempts at protecting Negro rights after the Civil War. Congress rewrote the Bill to obtain enough signatures and then passed it over the President’s Veto later in the year.


In addition to being a great writer, Kafka was a legal scholar and attorney who had earned a Juris Doctor degree.


Many politicians were arguing that giving the intelligence agencies more power to wiretap, bug and hack into personal communications despite the 4th Amendment’s strictures argued that the public was in rational fear of terror attacks and had a right to be protected.


The FBI had obtained a court order requiring apple to write software that could hack into a person's iPhone. Apple, with most other hi-tech companies in support, filed a motion with the court opposing the order. The FBI shortly thereafter withdrew its request for the order saying that they had found other solutions, when they had originally told the court that there were no other solutions.


Unfortunately there has been a history in America of some overzealous police officers and prosecutors who have gone after particular people for reasons of prejudice, politics, self aggrandisement, or honest but erroneous belief of guilt. The 4th Amendment has acted as wall in many cases, but unfortunately it is a wall that can be scaled by over zealous officials who will falsify their applications for warrants. Though not a total barrier to abuse, the 4th Amendment has been one of the major reasons that Amercans enjoy greater freedom that exists in other countries.


No Photo Available
  • Born: November 25, 1951
  • Nationality:
  • Profession:

Victoria Ann Roberts is a Senior United States District Judge of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan.