Arthur Balfour Quotes
The tyranny of majorities may be as bad as the tyranny of Kings.
Balfour, Arthur James. Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). House of Commons.
Many disagree with Hook. While there are few total societies as examples, recently they point to Pakistan where the Islamic majority not only tyrannized non-Muslims, but even Muslims who are not devout enough. Hooks opponents argue that tyranny of the majority is generally exhibited in areas. For example, the white American majority tyrannized the Black minority for the first 150 years of American history. Within local and state governments there are many more examples of Tyranny of the Majority. The Mormons tyrannized non Mormons when they first settled the Utah territory. The Mormons themselves had been tyrannized by Christian majorities throughout their trek from New York State to Utah.
This quotation is historically important because Davis clearly states the reason for the rebellion of the South. The anti-slave states were growing at a greater rate than the slave states and despite the greater voting power that a southerner had (a result of the 3/5 count of slaves for census purposes, and the Senate), the handwriting was on the wall and the majority of the United States was against the vicious institution of slavery and would make it unprofitable, impossible and/or illegal in the coming years. Southern slavery advocates saw this as a “tyranny of the majority” and therefore took up arms. In the early 20th century, apologists for the Southern rebellion tried to promote the idea that there were reasons other than slavery, but this quotation and the resolutions of the states who withdrew from the Union make it clear that the right to maintain slavery was the only significant issue. In that sense it was a States’ Rights issue, but the South was opposed to States’ Rights when it came to States refusing to return fugitive slaves when Federal Law required such under the Dred Scott Supreme Court Decision.
Arthur James Balfour, 1st Earl of Balfour, KG, OM, PC, FRS, FBA, DL was Prime Minister of the United Kingdom from 1902 to 1905. He was a member of the Conservative Party. As Foreign Secretary in the Lloyd George ministry, he issued the Balfour Declaration in 1917 on behalf of the cabinet.