John McGinnis Quotes
The Internet greatly facilitates betting pools called information or prediction markets that permit people to bet on the occurrence of future events. Such markets already gauge election results more accurately than polls do. If legalized and modestly subsidized, they could also foretell many policy results better than politicians or experts alone. We could then better predict the consequences of changes
John McGinnis Accelerating Democracy: Transforming Governance Through Technology Princeton University Press, 2013
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
The Labor Department never would commit to a recommendation. The Job Corps leadership examined the insufficient data and made their best guess which for the most part turned out to be right as the Job Corps was the most effective youth job training program in the history of the country. It and Head Start were the only two of the anti-poverty programs that were still operational into the 21st century. Supreme Court Justice Learned Hand expressed the same idea more generally in {482001}.
The mayor was confronted with a poll showing that over 70 percent of the public opposed taxpayer support for a sports stadium which would provide subsidies to profitable professional sports teams. Nonetheless he continued to support the idea believing that the issues were too complex for the public to understand.
In other words, don’t micromanage your agents.
See {630694} for a later, more specific instance where Hand’s principle was required operationally.
Many people have criticized our citation of this McKinley quotation. They observe that the quotation comes from McKinley’s Inaugural Address given in Washington DC on March 3. They are correct about the Inaugural address observation, but what they do not realize is that the President tried out this language two days before. As he left Canton Ohio, he made a short speech trying out this line before a small crowd with almost no press coverage. Satisfied with the reaction, he used it again in the Inaugural Address two days later. Our citation policy generally cites the first time the quotation was used, and that is on March 1 in Canton, Ohio.
We all have 20-20 hindsight, and sometimes well analyzed decisions turn out badly as the result of unfortunate circumstances.
This principle is very important in all kinds of human activity. We design and test or pilot test products and programs of all kinds—governmental and not. The testing may uncover a flaw or problem, but the failure to find flaws or problems does NOT mean that they are not inherent in the program—they may well be there and have not been uncovered by the tests. Often when this occurs, we refer to them as “unintended consequences.”
John Oldham McGinnis is a professor at Northwestern University Pritzker School of Law and author of over 90 academic and popular articles and essays. His popular writings have been published in The Wall Street Journal, National Review, and Policy Review.