Colin H. Kahl Quotes
The bare knuckles approach seems singularly unsuited to 21st century counterinsurgencies conducted by Western Democracies. The immoral and illegal use of indiscriminate violence would require abandoning the very values Western militaries claim to protect.
See {620373} for a contrary point of view. Arguably, the kind of ruthlessness that would be required to defeat an insurgency with a strictly military approach would require too brutal and barbarous treatment of civilians who may aid insurgents, that Modern Democracies with their open media are incapable of. In the US invasion of Iraq or the Israeli occupation of the West Bank, the total number of civilians killed by the military was tiny, compared to the 20 million Russians killed by the Germans in their attempted invasion of Russia. The entire Gaza war produced only about 1000 civilian deaths out of 1 million people was one tenth of one percent compared with the American civilian casualties at the hands of the British in 1776 was over 100 times greater.
Colin H. Kahl, Political Scientist & Fellow, Center for a New American Security, “Coin of the Realm”, Foreign Policy, November/December 2007
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
See {620373} for a similar quote. However, there are many who disagree. They point to the Vietnam War as just one counter example. Generally, this tactic has worked for non-democratic nations facing insurgents and terrorists, but has not been very successful for the United States, England, France, Israel and other industrial democracies. These societies have found it difficult to inflict enough terror in the general population to make Luttwak’s tactic effective. The norms and mores of the culture was contrary to the methods that are required, and public opinion forced cessation in the instances where industrial democracies had tried it such as France in Algeria. See {620377}.
See {620340} for a similar quote. However, there are many who disagree {620377} and who point to the Vietnam War as just one counter example. The American military leaders after not having very much success with Peters’ approach, shifted to one which placed high priority on hearts and minds and had more success. Arguably, the kind of ruthlessness that would be required to defeat an insurgency with a strictly military approach would require too brutal and barbarous treatment of civilians who may aid insurgents, that Modern Democracies with their open media are incapable of. In the US invasion of Iraq or the Israeli occupation of the West Bank, the total number of civilians killed by the military was tiny, compared to the 20 million Russians killed by the Germans in their attempted invasion of Russia. The entire Gaza war produced only about 1000 civilian deaths out of 1 million people was one tenth of one percent compared with the American civilian casualties at the hands of the British in 1776 was over 100 times greater.
Colin Hackett Kahl is an American political adviser and academic who served as the National Security Advisor to the Vice President of the United States. He is currently the Steven C. Házy Senior Fellow at Stanford University. President Joe Biden has nominated him to be the Under Secretary of Defense for Policy.