Kimberly Marten Quotes
Russian elites believe that he [President Vladimir Putin] serves the same function as the Czars of old, keeping diverse political clans and their leaders (the boyars) in balance, preventing the civil war or chaos that a country of Russia’s vast size and relative emptiness would face if it were left open to competition by those who retain loyal militias.
Kimberly Marten, Political Scientist, Book Review, Political, Science Quarterly, Fall 2014
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
For an earlier expression of this notion see James Madison.
This quotation provides an insight into Stalin’s bizarre and ruthless character.
The dictator that he thought Russia needed, Stalin, turned on him in 1937 for not agreeing with Stalin enthusiastically enough, had a 1 day trial for treason, and executed the best military man in the country despite the fact that Russia would need its military to fight the German invasion.
The example that is often given is Singapore of the late 20th century.
Such a comcept has been shared by most autocratic governments like Nazi Germany, but before and after Germans did not see this subservience to and power of the state as desirable or even necessary. The Vatican has had periods like this. But this Sistema has been a part of Russian culture during the millinium of Czarist rule. It was used andn explicitly made a part of Lennin and the Russian Revolutionaries, and then so heavily used by Joseph Stalin before, during and after WWII. It continued under the Post Stalinist Communist leader and when the Soviet Union fell and Russia became less authoratoran, it was not utilized but it was deeply embedded in the Russian psyche and culture as demonstrated by the fact that Vladimir Putin began t use it as an instrument of his governance.
Kimberly Marten is a foreign policy analyst, and Ann Whitney Olin Professor of Political Science at Barnard College. She graduated from Harvard University magna cum laude and from Stanford University with a Ph.D. She is Deputy Director for Development, at the Harriman Institute.