John White Chadwick Quotes


Of the six men who have done most to make America the wonder and the joy she is to all of us, not one could be the citizen of a government so constituted; for Washington and Franklin and Jefferson, certainly the three mightiest leaders in our early history, were heretics in their day, Deists, as men called them; and Garrison and Lincoln and Sumner, certainly the three mightiest in these later times, would all be disfranchised by the proposed amendment. Lincoln could not have taken the oath of office had such a clause been in the Constitution.


Context

In 1872 a proposed Constitutional amendment was debated throughout much of the country. The proposed “Christian Amendment” to the Constitution, recognized the Bible, God, and made Christianity the state religion requiring religious tests of public officials including belonging to an organized Christian Church. “Deists” as used then referred to people who had a general belief in a Supreme Being but did not belong to any formal or organized church.


Citations

John White Chadwick, 1840-1904, Unitarian Minister, Address delivered in Tremout Temple, Boston, May 30, 1872

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

Opponents of the strict separation of church and state use this quotation to support their view. However, Story herein describes public sentiment, not what was passed and ratified in the Constitution and Bill of Rights. See {614309} and {614310} for his statements from the same work that show that there was no question in his mind but that church and state are separated by the Constitution and the First Amendment.


Huckabee, a fundamentalist Christian Minister in addition to being a politician, had been very tolerant of other religions and their rights. However, on the abortion question he seemed to be calling for a Constitutional amendment to make abortion illegal. The likelihood of passing such a Constitutional Amendment given the supermajority requirement was very low given the national division on this polarizing issue. A very careful reading of the candidate’s statement shows that he never literally advocated an amendment. He just stated that is would be easier to change the Constitution than to change the world of God which to believers was immutable. Thus his statement was true, yet some interpreted it as a very clever way of making a moral statement without committing to a course of action that would deny women the right to make decisions over the use and risks to their own bodies, souls, and lives.


John White Chadwick
John White Chadwick
  • Born: October 19, 1840
  • Died: December 11, 1904
  • Nationality:
  • Profession: Theologian

John White Chadwick was an American writer and clergyman of the Unitarian Church.