William Harper Quotes


Odium has been cast upon our legislation on account of its forbidding the elements of education to be communicated to slaves. But, in truth, what injury is done to them by this? He who works during the day with his hands does not read in the intervals of his leisure for his amusement or the improvement of his mind. If there were any chance of their elevating their rank and condition in society, it might be a matter of hardship that they should be denied those rudiments of knowledge which open the way to further attainments.


Context

This was an example of the circular logic that defense of slavery produced. Slaves are not interested in education. If they were it would be bad to deny them an education to advance themselves. But since a slave cannot advance, the point is moot and there is no reason to educate a slave even if he or she wanted an education.


Citations

William Harper, 1790-1847, U. S. Congressman (Jacksonian Democrat, SC), Chancellor of South Carolina, 1837

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

The Emperor was then only 20 years old and it is doubtful that this was actually written by him personally or even that he was the originator or driver of this policy—probably the strongest statement regarding education of any nation in history. Nonetheless, it is a great quotation on the role of education in the nation. He even ordained that all girls should be educated—an achievement which had not been achieved by the majority of countries 140 years later in 2012. Most incredible about this quotation is that the Emperor made everything else of importance subordinate to the education of children." Meiji the Great


This quotation is interesting for two reasons. First it is a good example of the twisted logic of some of the Slavery apologists who claimed that the Negro slave was better off than the free wage earner. The second reason is that it illustrates the norms of the treatment of the working man before the Civil War. The union movement would change the situation for the free laborer over the next century and then holidays and worker rights became normalized in American society. See {641290} for another of his absurd arguments.


She was referring to Malala, a young Pakistani girl who was shot and badly wounded in an assassination attempt. She had publicly advocated girls attendance at school—a practice banned by the ultra-fundamentalist Taliban.


William Harper
William Harper
  • Born: January 17, 1790
  • Died: October 10, 1847
  • Nationality:
  • Profession:

William Joseph Harper was a jurist, politician, and social and political theorist from South Carolina.