Vernon Lyman Kellogg Quotes


In the case of the mortality from war it is precisely this testing of the whole population, this randomness of exposure to its causes, that does not obtain. To my mind the immediate and the sufficient answer to the claims of those who see in war a biologically race-purifying agent, is the exposure of the character of the selection which war's mortality and injuries entail. Military selection is as far as possible removed from natural selection. It is peculiarly unnatural.


Context

See {631151} for the argument that Kellogg counters here. The bizarre theory is that in war, the less fit individuals get killed, while the survivors who are “superior” live on to breed and improve the human race. The absurdity is that casualties of war are mostly random and if anything, the bravest are killed.


Citations

Vernon Lyman Kellogg, 1867-1937, Writer, Entomologist, Evolutionary Biologist, “Eugenics And Militarism”, The Atlantic Monthly, July 1913

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Linked Quotes

This quotation illustrates the bizarre logic used by some war enthusiasts once Darwin’s evolutionary principles received wide distribution. Kellogg explains their notion. The absurdity is that there is nothing that characterizes the soldiers who lived differentially from the soldiers who died. The survivors of a bomb if any are random or determined by position and not intellect, courage, strength or any other trait that might be used selectively. See Kellogg’s explanation {631167}.


Related Quotes
Vernon Lyman Kellogg
Vernon Lyman Kellogg
  • Born: December 1, 1867
  • Died: August 8, 1937
  • Nationality:
  • Profession:

Vernon Lyman Kellogg was an American entomologist, evolutionary biologist, and science administrator. His father was Lyman Beecher Kellogg, first president of the Kansas State Normal School (now known as Emporia State University), and former Kansas Attorney General. In 1908, Kellogg married Charlotte Hoffman and the two welcomed their only child, Jean Kellogg Dickie, in 1910.