Joel I. Klein Quotes
If the forces behind [education] reform seem scattered and weak those defending the status quo—the unions, the politicians, the bureaucrats, and the vendors—are well organized and well financed…. I am convinced that without a major realignment of political forces, we won’t get the dramatic improvements our children need.
His only educational experience was as the NYC Chancellor and the situation he describes was the case there and at many other locations in the country. However, there are some school systems where these forces have locally aligned some years ago and they have great school systems. In a few cases (like Montgomery County, Maryland) the great school system was produced without any alignment of power. They have one of the highest rates of terminating teachers who are not good, but it is the Union which makes the decisions.
Joel I. Klein, Chancellor, New York City School System, Assistant Attorney General, Antitrust Division (Democrat), “Scenes from the Class Struggle”, The Atlantic, June 2011
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
This historical quotation gives us an understanding of why rural schools have been behind urban and suburban schools. The poor, rural communities did not have the resources to pay for a first class education.
Black and Hispanic student performance on educational achievement tests were much lower than that of whites. There were many who believed that this gap was responsible for most of the other ethnic differences that made for ethnic and racial inequality. Ironically, it was Romney’s party in Congress that opposed more funding for education and generally was opposed to federal efforts to improve and monitor civil rights. However, Romney was talking to a mostly Hispanic audience and took a position that was seemingly contradictory to his Party’s Platform and the actions of the then Republican Controlled House of Representatives.
One important observation of this quotation is the pejorative language Mises used to describe “Union Bosses” as opposed to “Union Leaders.” There were indeed a few Union “Bosses” but most unions had popularly elected leaders. It is similar to the left wing critic who refers to Corporate Executives as “Greedy Monopolists.” A few are but most are not. Historically, in the last half of the 20th century and the beginning of the 21st, the conservatives tended to be much better at pejorative language and used it more frequently and uniformly than the liberals who tended to be better in the last part of the 19th century and the first half of the 20th century.
Compare this quotation with {632899}. Most members of Congress had limited management experience and the only solution to an organizational problem was to fire people. The referenced quotation has people fired for the purpose of inspiring public trust; in this quotation, it is to trigger reform and change. Ironically, there is no evidence in the management literature that suggests that firing for either of these reasons will have the desired objective.
Political conservatives have generally been very verbal in their attacks upon and criticisms of bureaucracy. And yet, bureaucrats are the epitome of conservatism in their outlook and mode of operation as is made clear by this quotation.
Joel Irwin Klein is an American lawyer and school superintendent. He was the Chancellor of the New York City Department of Education, the largest public school system in the United States, serving more than 1.1 million students in more than 1,600 schools. He was succeeded by Cathie Black in January 2011.