James F. Byrnes Quotes
We have helped to organize the United Nations. We believe it will stop aggressor nations from starting wars. Because we believe it, we intend to support the United Nations organization with all the power and resources we possess.
Byrnes, James F. "Restatement of Policy on Germany." Department of State Bulletin, vol. 15, no. 376, 15 Sept. 1946, pp. 496-501.
Clark, a conservative, was one of those who did not believe that the United Nations or any international organization have any enforcement powers but should just be a forum for deliberation. By the end of the 20th century one of the major conservative complaints about the United Nations was that it could not enforce its resolutions and was a paper tiger.
This was a very important statement for the President to make. At the time there was a very conservative right wing that was advocating withdrawing from the UN or at the very least not paying such a large share of the UN funds for operation.
1st Earl Lloyd-George of Dwyfor. International organizations have been notoriously inept at protecting countries from aggression or minorities from persecution and ethnic cleansing and genocide. The Armenian genocide by the Turks was the exemplar at the time, but the UN peacekeepers refused to fight to prevent the Serbs from murdering 7,000 Bosnian Muslims. When they were protecting the Israeli-Palestinian borders, they did nothing to stop Arab Armies from attacking Israel right through the UN Troops. They did nothing to help prevent the Ruanda genocide. UN “troops” are rarely willing to risk their lives for the victimized people or the International Organization itself.
3rd Earl Russell of Kingston. The military weak nations agreed with him, but the militarily strong ones did not—especially America and England which had the Atomic Bomb when others did not.
One major problem at the time was that the Soviet Union was supporting and instigating revolutions in many parts of the world. When most nations of the UN wanted to provide peace keeping troops to quell the conflict, the Russians would veto and block the effort, Vandenberg wanted the UN to change the rules regarding the veto. The original right of veto for the major nations was originally included at the insistence of the United States and many Americans did not want to give it up or have any exceptions lest there be more. The Russians at that time also did not want to give up any of their veto powers. Another method that Vandenberg wanted to solve the Russian peacekeeping blockage problem was for America to engage in more collective security pacts so that action could be taken without UN Security Council unanimity by going around the UN.
Actually it was the United States which insisted in the veto which required consensus of the great powers of the time. It was Russia which ended up using it far more often than any other nation.
James Francis Byrnes was an American judge and politician from the state of South Carolina. A member of the Democratic Party, Byrnes served in Congress, the executive branch, and on the United States Supreme Court. He was also the 104th governor of South Carolina, making him one of the very few politicians to have served in the highest levels of all three branches of the American federal government while also being active in state government.