Nikolay Kostomarov Quotes
Ukraine is lying in the grave, but she has not died, and her voice, calling on all Slavs to liberty and brotherhood, resounded throughout the Slav world.
Nikolay Kostomarov, 1817-1885, Historian & Ukrainian Slavic Nationalist, The Books of the Birth of the Ukranian People
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
The notion that a the first line of a national anthem should be focused on the survival of the nation is explained by the history of countries that have and have not existed having been overrun and occupied and absorbed into other nations. That fear exists centuries later. See Poland for another example {642422}.
See also {612345} for a contemporary description of the Slavs.
The United States, since its inception has always had an empathy for other peoples who sought independence, but at the same time we had an early principle of isolationism and not getting involved with quarrels abroad. Also America was inhibited by other unrelated issues from assisting people seeking independence.
At the partition if India into Hindu and Muslim States, what is now Bangladesh, was a part of Pakistan called “East Pakistan” by the Pakistani government. While India became a thriving democracy, Pakistan with its combination of military strongmen and Islamic Fundamentalists did not fare as well and became a very corrupt, undemocratic military nation. East Pakistan was not contiguous with the rest of Pakistan and was culturally quite different and less religiously fundamentalist. While all Pakistanis suffered from poor government, the East Pakistanis fared worse. Finally, they developed their own identity which was suppressed by the military dictators of Pakistan and the Banglas revolted and Bangladesh became and independent nation.
Historically Ukraine has been not only a part of Russia but a key part. The first Russian leader who unified the Russian nation and fought off the Mongols and Roman Catholic Western invaders came from the Ukraine. The origin of the Russian Orthodox Church was in the Ukraine. And the people of the Ukraine played a central and pivotal role in the Russian Revolution. And in World War II, despite a minoirty of Ukrainian nationalists who fought with the Nazis, the Ukraine bore much of the brunt of the German onslaught and the 22 million Russians who were killed, and yet fought so well that the Nazis were defeated. Many of the great Russian Heroes have been from the Ukraine. From the Russian point of view, Ukraine, was noi less a part of Russia than Florida, Iowa or Nebraska were to the United States.
The irony is that the Zionist movement was very democratic long before most of the world had adopted democracy. They not only saw no conflict between a Jewish Homeland and democracy, but they maintained that Jewish tradition required democracy. After 60 years if constant attacks by its neighbors and having to defend the nation from invasion and extinction, the Israeli body politic actually became very conservative, while the Zionists were extremely left wing. Under the concept of Zionism there was a large population of Arabs as Israeli citizens. However, when some of those Arabs were openly against the nation in its struggle with the Palestinians and its other Muslim neighbors. Leiberman led the right wing effort in various efforts to expel the dissident Arab citizens and use very non democratic methods to cope with the right wing’s perception of the risk to the Jewish State.
Nikolay Ivanovich Kostomarov was one of the most distinguished Russian Imperial historians, a Professor of Russian History at the St. Vladimir University of Kiev and later at the St. Petersburg University, an Active State Councillor of Russia, an author of many books, including his famous biography of the seventeenth century Hetman of Zaporozhian Cossacks Bohdan Khmelnytsky, the research on the Ataman of Don Cossacks Stepan Razin and his fundamental 3-volume Russian History in Biographies of its main figures (Russian: Русская история в жизнеописаниях её главнейших деятелей).