Polly Toynbee Quotes


This is indeed a clash of civilisations, not between Islam and Christendom but between reason and superstition.


Citations

Toynbee, Polly. "Religion must be taken on and defeated." The Guardian, Guardian News & Media, 27 Oct. 2001.

Related Quotes

At the time, Muslim clerics had a great deal of influence and in many cases legal control over all facets of Turkish society much as exists in other Islamic societies today. They even controlled what was taught in the schools. Remarkably, without bloodshed, Ataturk broke both the power and the influence of the clerics on all official and public activities. Many Turkish Muslims even developed a type of reformed Islam with the relationship between the individual and the clerics one of parity much like Protestant churches in the West. At the same time there was a more orthodox part of the population and while they sent their children to religious schools, they also attended public schools so even the orthodox Muslims in Turkey learned science and modern subjects which are still not taught in most Islamic schools and madrassas.


One of the reasons that this quotation is so significant is that the Roman Catholic Church had been historically antithetical to science and scientists. It took hundreds of years before the church would admit that Galileo was right and the church wrong about the earth revolving around the sun. But Pope John Paul II, along with his other major accomplishments removed the traditional Catholic hostility in theology and tradition. He even acknowledged the validity of the Theory of Evolution and taught that there was nothing inherent in evolution that denied God or scripture.


Traditionally Islam was a religion of faith and since it was spread to illiterate and uneducated people, it was dogmatic and literal. Reason and logic was not a part of the theology originally. As Islamic societies developed intellectually, the theology matured and reason and logic was overlaid from the science and the technology to the religion. There were many very sophisticated philosophers and theologians until Islam closed intellectually and went into its decline. Just as there were few Islamic scientists and philosophers during the Enlightenment there were few theologians who appreciated the role of logic. Those few, like Abduh, had to become reformers and modernists and return to the era when Islam was as more modern than Christianity and most other religions.


Turkey had become a modern, secular nation under the leadership of Ataturk. At the time of this interview, a religious party had won a plurality of seats in the Parliament and while not rolling back the secular nature of the Turkish state which is enshrined in the Turkish Constitution, has tried to stem the tide of secularism.


Polly Toynbee
Polly Toynbee
  • Born: December 27, 1946
  • Nationality: British
  • Profession: Journalist, Writer

Mary Louisa "Polly" Toynbee is a British journalist and writer. She has been a columnist for The Guardian newspaper since 1998.