Charles Dudley Warner Quotes
The thing generally raised on city land is taxes.
Warner, Charles Dudley. My Summer in a Garden. Fields, Osgood, & Co., 1871, p. 10.
This Supreme Court opinion nullified the attempt to have a Federal Income Tax. The constitution allowed the Federal Government to collect import duties and that was essentially the only revenue source for the national government for over a century. If free trade were an objective, then customs duties would be lowered or eliminated and the Federal Govern lost the revenue. The only kind of direct tax that was allowed was a head tax in which every American paid the same tax. This was not a “flat tax” which means a tax where each person pays the same PERCENTAGE of income as tax. This meant that the richest person in the nation could only pay what the poorest could afford and therefore was impractical. It would take a constitutional amendment 18 years later—the 16th Amendment—to make the income tax legal. Many extremist anti-Federal government have refused to pay their income taxes and they argue that “The Supreme Court has declared the Income Tax illegal.” While that is so, after the 16th Amendment, the Court agreed that it was now constitutional. So the implication of unconstitutionality of the Federal Income Tax that the anti-tax forces have used was the law but has not been so since 1913. After that, it was and is perfectly legal and constitutional.
This is the most articulate historical statement of the modern conservative mantra regarding taxes. However, one change has taken place. The words “necessarily” and “often” tend to be left out of the more modern ideological statements. Mellon’s original statement has never really had any politicians or economists who disagreed. Politicians of all economic persuasions have generally accepted the Mellon statement but the extreme conservatives’ creed is that a lowering of taxes always produces more revenue and a tax increase will inevitably lead to greater tax revenue—a position which Mellon never took. Mellon however was very solicitous of the wealthy, felt the welfare of the nation depended on their prosperity, and was a strong advocate of what was later called ‘trickle down’ economics {628592}.
He turned out to be very wrong as there were a number of times in American history when there were tax rates in excess of 70 percent, and they were collected.
See {634234} and {634238} for more of his arguments at the Ratification Convention.
This quotation was very important because the most important economic principle of Republican ideology since the 1960s has been that tax cuts will produce economic growth and the converse: that tax increases will stifle economic growth. For 50 years the Republican nostrum for all economic problems has been to increase growth by cutting taxes and opposing all tax increases. However Leonhardt studied the data and results since 1987 and found that the Republican doctrine had been wrong. Economic growth plummeted when we had the largest tax cuts in the George W. Bush years and the greatest growth spurts were following the 1990 George W. Bush tax increase and the 1993 Bill Clinton tax cuts. When the data became public some Republicans took the view that taxes were just one of the factors determining economic growth and have been overwhelmed by other factors. Some Democrats argue that if this were really believed by Republicans, they would have favored these other factors more so than tax cuts when in fact tax cuts are always their nostrum.
Charles Dudley Warner was an American essayist, novelist, and friend of Mark Twain, with whom he co-authored the novel The Gilded Age: A Tale of Today.