Sarah Chayes Quotes


The Government of Afghanistan could best be understood, not as a government at all, but as a vertically integrated criminal organization whose care activity was not in fact exercising the functions of a state, but of rather extracting resources for personal gain.


Context

Many government officials realized this, but soft pedaled the information lest the American public's negative reaction might have been to reduce or cut off support to the American effort to stabilize and protect Afghanistan from the Taliban, Islamic, Fundamentalist, Extremist Terrorists. They chose what they believed to be the lesser of two evils. If the Taliban could be defeated, then attention might be turned to reforming the government and getting rid of Karzai. Others that that was a great mistake and Karzai should be deposed first, because as long as the corruption permeated the entire Afghan government, the population would never support a government and fight to get rid of the Taliban.


Citations

Sarah Chayes, Special Strategic Advisor to the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Senior Fellow, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Developer of Afghan Development Organizations, Journalist & Author, Thieves of State: Why Corruption Threatens Global Security, 2015

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

She assisted the Family of the Afghanistan President, Hamid Karzai in the early 2000s, hoping to establish a non-profit public service organization. Once it was operating she realized that the origination had a murkey accounting system and the "first family" was extracting money from the organization.


In this context, “rent" means payment is required for the use or right to use anything such as using land for a pipeline, for mining, prospecting for oil, the rights to fish for caviar sturgeon, erecting a building, obtaining an official document, etc. The Russian economic system and culture has created a striving for getting paid to grant rights as opposed to getting paid for making something, creating something, or performing a service for someone. In the breakup of the Soviet Union, some individuals obtained (by various means) the right to charge rent to others for much of the great trove of Russian land, waters and other natural resources. They became billionaires – oligarchs – and many are still paying off government officials to control those rights.


The United States had just ousted the popularly elected leader Patrice Lumumba {640611}, and backed Mobuto. Lumumba was an idealist who was not corrupt at all, but were not so sure about our new protégé. Sadly he turned out to be one of the worst kleptocrats of all time, and he stole with more United States money than we gave to many nations in toto. Many believe that one of the reasons, corruption of our “allied” leaders was so bad lies in the wording of this cable. Note that to the State Department writers there was “normal” corruption as opposed to excessive corruption. Once that view is taken there is a constant battle to determine whether each new act of corruption is “normal “ or not, and corruption is simply lessened by pushing back against the most abnormal schemes. These critics advocate a zero tolerance for corruption especially with United States AID money. The State Department has been ambivalent and have often used the corruption system to bribe leaders to obtain national objectives.


Sarah Chayes
Sarah Chayes
  • Born: March 5, 1962
  • Nationality:
  • Profession: Senior Associate, Carnegie Endowment For International Peace

Sarah Chayes is a former senior associate in the Democracy and Rule of Law Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, leaving in order to pursue a new writing project. A former award-winning reporter for National Public Radio, she also served as special advisor to the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.