Sophia Murphy Quotes


The Government in the US has become responsible for farmers’ income, leaving the big (transnational) buyers in the market free to exploit their oligopolistic position


Citations

Sophia Murphy, Canadian Political Economist, Senior Advisor, Canadian Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy, “Market Power In Agricultural Markets: Some Issues For Developing Countries”, working paper, no. 6, November 1999

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

Herbert Hoover was then the Food Administrator and in part with his assistance, Congress passed The Food Control Law August, 1917 which contained a provision, guaranteeing a wheat price to the farmer of two dollars a bushel. This was the beginning of Agricultural Subsidies and Corporate welfare for the large farm companies. It was passed under the Democratic Wilson Administration but Republican Herbert Hoover was one of the major supporters.


While this statement seems totally absurd to us today, at the time most politicians and judges believed it. Only the left wingers and the populists opposed the doctrine as well as most business owners who knew the truth but of course most preferred the have their own monopoly. One of the reasons the large American corporations did not want Jewish and Chinese immigrants is that those cultures supported highly competitive businesses and might give consumers a better deal or worse, their culture would argue for less monopoly and more competition. For more than half a century AT&T was given a monopoly over almost all telephone service in the United States. Finally the Federal Courts saw through the company propaganda, and ordered AT&T broken up. The “Baby Bells” have persuaded most state legislatures and regulatory bodies of this same argument, and almost every community of the United States has a monopoly on local wired local telephone service. The same is true about water and electricity and a great deal of American transportation. Every major company strives for as much of a monopolistic position the government will allow; some are overt like the electrical companies. Others are more subtle and use copyright and patents to be sure that there is no price or service competition. Fortunately, the high tech industry is to technologically competitive that prices have been have been going down constantly not like telephone and Internet connectivity, entertainment, education, and professional services.


One irony that some critics of Murdoch’s enterprises make is that despite his personal views about monopoly his businesses try to attain and maintain monopoly status whenever it can.


Actually, the Agriculture Department was one of Lincoln’s greatest achievements. The subsidies and corporate welfare came much later. The biggest benefits were the land grant collages where agricultural research improved the yields and productivity and the Agricultural Extension provided training and technical assistance to American farmers making the United States the most efficient agricultural producer in the world. The subsidies and corporate welfare had and has nothing to do with the positive initiatives that Lincoln envisioned.


There were not many large companies in the agribusiness selling chemicals, fertilizers, pesticides and seeds to the farmers of America. When there was an attempted merger, the regulators were supposed to make sure that the merger press would not be responsible for higher prices as with the merger, there would be less competition. As Holcomb said in this quotation, the companies would typically tell the regulators how they merger would produce synergistic cost savings for the farm products. And in theory that wold be true in most cases. However once the company receives approval, the tend to claim the products are losing money and they must raise prices. And often that is true but the main reason for the loss is the cost of the money that they usually borrowed to pay for the acquisition.


No Photo Available
  • Born:
  • Nationality:
  • Profession: