Roger Sherman Quotes
State Legislatures were better qualified to elect the Members than the people were
Roger Sherman, 1721-1793, U. S. Congressman (Connecticut), Judge of the Connecticut Superior Court, Mayor of New Haven, Connecticut Delegate to the Constitutional Convention, Quoted in the notes of Georgia Delegate William Leigh Pierce, ~1740-1789
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
This Pinkney view prevailed in the original Constitution, but this practice was reversed by the 17th Amendment of 1913. The source for this statement is the notes of Alexander Hamilton.
The conservative Senator was very distrustful of the constitutional amendment process itself after a both prohibition and women's suffrage amendments had passed. Wadsworth and his supporters feared Constitutional amendments passed by Congress and the State legislatures without any direct approval of the people.
At the time the power and prestige of Congress relative to the Presidency , was much greater than it is today. It was McKinley’s successor, Theodore Roosevelt, who began a 20th century trend which led to a reversal of the relationship between the Executive Branch and the Legislative.
In the EU most of the government power is dominated by appointed elites and not elected representatives.
At the time, the convention delegates picked the party Presidential nominee without any direct role of the voters. The so called “smoke-filled room” of party bosses. When TR decided to run again for the Presidency there was an incumbent Republican President, Taft. However most Republicans in the country preferred Roosevelt who had served two very successful terms as President. But there were no primary elections in those days and there was no way for the party voters preferences to heavily influence the process. The Party bosses, who never liked TR because of his independence, nominated Taft. Roosevelt ran as a 3rd party candidate and actually out polled Taft. However, the Democrat, Woodrow Wilson got more votes than Roosevelt, who would have easily won if the republicans had nominated TR as the majority of the party wanted.
Most Americans are unaware that Congress has the power to redraw State Congressional District lines.
Benton's solution was for the people to elect the President and Vice President directly.
Two years later with bipartisan support Speaker Joseph Cannon was stripped of his party and the Rules Committee was created.
Roger Sherman was an early American statesman and lawyer, as well as a Founding Father of the United States. He is the only person to have signed all four great state papers of the United States: the Continental Association, the Declaration of Independence, the Articles of Confederation, and the Constitution.