Edward R. Korman Quotes


politically motivated and scientifically unjustified frivolous and silly arguments corrupted by political interference largely an insult to the intelligence of women


Context

The FDA had studied for years the safety and efficacy and concluded that Morning After pill contraceptive, Plan B was safe and effective and could be sold over the counter. However when the Department of Health and Human Services issued the regulations to allow it to be sold over the counter without a prescription they disallowed sale to girls under 15. Several religious organizations opposed to birth control pressured the administration to overrule the FDA and they did so partially trying to compromise. However, the science showed no differential factors of risk for girls under 15 and a suit were filed by women’s and public health groups to eliminate the age restriction. Judge Korman found that the government had acted illegally in imposing an age restriction with no scientific evidence to justify it. The Plan B contraceptive was particularly contentious for religious groups as it as a “morning after” pill—it is taken AFTER intercourse and thus is considered abortion by some anti abortion groups. What made the case more embarrassing for the Obama Administration is that Obama campaigned against the common practice of the George W. Bush administration of ignoring the science or distorting it in policy making. Upon inauguration, President Obama issued executive orders to all departments to follow science in their decision making. Then in this case, they did just what the Bush administration had done—overruled the science to pander to or mollify a particular pressure group.


Citations

Edward R. Korman, Federal Judge, Statements chastising the Obama Administration’s attempt to restrict the Morning After pill contraceptive, Plan B to girls over 15 years of age, Quoted in Elizabeth Rosenthal, “Is It Time for Off-The-Shelf Birth-Control Pills”, New York Times, April 21, 2013

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

If a state or community legally decides that a fetus is a person, there are many situations where there is a conflict of interest between the mother to be and the fetus. A pregnant woman, having a single drink of alcohol, potentially dangers the fetus (called Fetal Alcohol Syndrome). Smoking is clearly hazardous to the health of the fetus (underweight babies and more infant mortality and even more SIDS deaths. A diet to keep a mother thinner may not be nutritious for the fetus, A few states and local government have started prosecuting pregnant women for their personal behavior that might be detrimental to the fetus—often the purpose is to assert the right of the state to regulate the behavior of the pregnant woman so that the state can control abortion.


Edward R. Korman
Edward R. Korman
  • Born: October 25, 1942
  • Nationality:
  • Profession:

Edward Robert Korman is a Senior United States District Judge serving on the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York, in Brooklyn, New York.