R. Alta Charo Quotes


Physicians would have to inform pregnant women of the risks of childbirth and motherhood. They would have to note that childbirth, compared to abortion is 14 times more likely to result in maternal death and is more often associated with depression and other forms of mental illness, They would have to emphasize that working women in the United States can expect their wages to drop 9 to 16 percent for each child, and that having a child makes it significantly more likely that an unmarried woman will ever marry.


Context

This is a brilliant example of political sarcasm to make an important political point. In an effort to evade the Supreme Court Roe v. Wade decision giving women the right to have an abortion, Virginia and several other very conservative states began to pass laws that put impediments in the way of women wanting abortions and/or increasing the cost and hassle of abortion. Virginia passed legislation requiring physicians who might do aboutions to first council the woman in all the risks and negatives of abortion. The “purpose of the act” was supposedly to protect the woman and her rights. However there was no requirement of a physician to communicate the risks of childbirth and so Virginia by this quotation is exposed by only caring about a woman considering abortion being informed of risk, but not worrying about protecting the pregnant woman who is contemplating birth. Charo takes the Virginia statute and rewrites it to apply to women expecting to give birth and requiring the physicians to describe those risks. In the process of creating a parallel law for women interested in giving birth, Charo then is able to show that with the state of medicine at the early 21st century, it was much more risky to give birth than to have an abortion. Anti-abortion believers rarely say (and many do not even know) that the mother to be risks a higher rate of maternal mortality than the woman who chooses abortion. Abortion foes emphasize the mental health implications of having an abortion, yet there was no scientific evidence that it did. There were MANY research studies, however, that mental health problems are a very real risk of childbirth. (Post Partum depression is quite common when the female hormones radically change during pregnancy and childbirth. And ironically Charo would have the obstetrician warn about the economic and social risks of giving birth, just as the Virginia statute required warnings about abortion.


Citations

R. Alta Charo, Legal Scholar & Essayist, “Defending the Rights of Mothers to Be”, The Washington Post, May 26, 2013

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

Mrs. Roosevelt made issues national by the use of her daily column which was a type of blog with newspapers. Here she focused on a major health problem. At the time, Mrs. Roosevelt saw this as a women’s issue which of course it was. Government spent large sums of money to minimize or prevent death of men in war, but almost nothing on the problem of women’s death in childbirth despite the fact that many more women were killed than men. Unfortunately, while not to the same degree or proportion, the problem is still with us. With our wonderful modern medicine, we have increased the lifespan of most Americans markedly, but there are still many women who receive no prenatal care or counseling with the negative consequence.


Walsh claimed that there was no longer a single case of a woman who dies in childbirth. Over 600 women died that year during childbirth in the United States.


At the time, condoms and other forms of contraceptives were illegal to buy, sell, possess or own. As late as 1963 a Connecticut druggist was sentenced to jail for filling a doctor’s prescription for condoms and selling them to a married couple even thought the woman might die if she again became pregnant. The Supreme Court (Griswald v. Connecticut) established that a woman had a right to control her own reproductive cycle and the government had no business interfering with a privacy right possessed by a couple. Roe v. Wade established the right to an abortion. The same moral compunctions used with abortion were, and still are used by some to oppose any form of artificial birth control. They argued: preventing a life was as serious a moral failure as taking one. Many Catholics, many evangelical and fundamentalist protestants, and some orthodox Muslims are today morally opposed to birth control and believe that the government should ban birth control as it once was in the United States.


The argument she made is that a woman should not be required to risk her life if she does not want to. Other than military conscription, there is no other aspect of American law whereby the society forces a citizen to risk their life.


The ruling allowed GE's employee disability insurance plan to exclude conditions arising from pregnancy. Many critics argue that the same policies paid for Viagra for men which is also significantly different.


Dr. Noel Browne, the Minister of Health, in an attempt to reduce the infant and maternal mortality rate proposed a plan whereby the local government medical officers could treat and advise women regarding reproduction, pregnancy and childbirth. The Roman Catholic hierarchy send this letter to the Irish President who had already pledged to follow the teachings of the Catholic hierarchy—{639725} and {639726}. After the letter was received, Browne who had had no previous objections from the President or any of the cabinet, could not get a single vote in the cabinet for his proposal, and shortly thereafter he was forced to resign. The infant and maternal health statistics for the Irish Free State continued to lag that of Britain, France, Germany and Italy.


No Photo Available
  • Born:
  • Nationality:
  • Profession:

Robin Alta Charo (born 1958) is the Warren P. Knowles Professor of Law and Bioethics at the University of Wisconsin–Madison and a leading American authority on bioethics. She holds appointments in both Wisconsin's law school and medical school.