Roger Cohen Quotes
Israel is now a modern society. Its per capita income is higher than Spain’s. But behind the sheen of economic success, the shadow of undefined borders and violence always lurks.
Israel is the only state in the overwhelming Muslim Middle East that is modern, democratic, Jewish, Western, and technologically based. It’s presence has been an embarrassment for all the Arab States in the region as Israel, founded in 1948 on some of the worst land of the Middle East with no oil or other natural resources developed from a desert in a short term, while the other states have remained backward, poor, and dictatorial. The Arabs have opposed Israel ever since its creation by the United Nations and have attacked it in numerous wars since then which the Arabs have all lost along with control of the traditional Palestinian lands which the Israelis occupy and control as a security measure. Only Egypt has accepted the existence of Israel as a Jewish State and entered into a peach treaty. The others still threaten Israel constantly and provide arms and ammunition to terrorists who frequently attack Israeli civilians while Israeli religious extremists, who believe that God gave much of the region to the Jewish People and have created settlements on Palestinian land, giving many Palestinians a just grievance to go along with the hostility that had already existed.
Roger Cohen Why Israel Still Refuses to Choose The New York Times, October 28, 2016
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
This was one of the most accurate foreign policy assessments ever made. The next year the first Arab-Israeli war began when the state of Israel came into being. See {624566} for another accurate prediction.
Arab terrorists were raiding Israel. The United States, not yet having experienced September 11 was urging Israel not to retaliate and quietly allow diplomacy to operate.
Hamas, a terrorist group, however had taken over the Gaza Strip by force, ousting the Fatah Palestinian government. Hamas were then the de facto dictatorial rulers of almost 2 million Palestinians while the Fatah Government controls the West Bank with most of the Palestinians.
For years of the Arab-Israeli conflict, Palestinians would never negotiate with Israel over anything. Finally that barrier was broken and, the PLO became a negotiating party with Israel. However, the terrorist organization Hamas, had challenged the PLO for political control of the Palestinians and then took over the Gaza strip—part of the Palestinian territory. They then shot thousands of rockets into Israel, a clear act of war under international law. The Israelis then attacked the Hamas infrastructure and any building of facility where they had command or communications, meetings, trainings or stored weapons or ammunitions. The Gazans suffered many more casualties than the Israelis—about 20 to 1 ratio. Many other countries tried to broker a ceasefire which the Israelis agreed to but Hamas would not. The Israeli ambassador was asked on American television if Israel would be willing to negotiate on the larger issues of the conflict as they had negotiated with the PLO. This was his reply. The major problem was that the Hamas Charter had two clauses that made negotiations impossible. Hamas was committed to the destruction of Israel and would not agree that the Israel had a right to exist. Second, the Hamas charter called for the killing of Jews anywhere in the world—men, women and children. The Israelis asked what they would negotiate about given those two charter items and the Hamas terror history in killing as many Israelis as they could.
Roger Cohen is a journalist and author. He has been a columnist for The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times and International New York Times. He has worked as a foreign correspondent in fifteen different countries.