Calum MacKellar Quotes
In some countries the effort to debate and legislate the social and ethical implications of the new biological and genetic technologies often precedes their application. This observation confirms the realization by the public that biotechnological applications will interfere with all the basic and profound value systems considered by every human being
Calum MacKellar, Canadian Ethicist, Editorial, European Journal of Genetics in Society Vol.1 No.1, 1995
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
This was written over 2 decades before Dolly the sheep was first cloned. Since his call for a societal public discussion about cloning, there has been very little, but by the 21st century there had been just a few hasty, ill-informed, almost hysterical efforts to legislate on the subject.
Venter developed an entirely new method of finding new species and hence new genes by collecting water samples from all over the world and using computers to catalog all the life forms and determine whether or not each is new and then isolating the genes if unique. As a very wealthy business man he had a personal sailing yacht which he turned over to graduate students and young scientists who then sailed much of the world taking indiscriminate samples, preserving them and sending them back to Venter’s computer bank for analysis. The cost per gene and specie discovered was amazingly small as it was an industrialization of finding new life forms.
He was commenting on a proposal many in public health were making of using modern technology, genetic and chemical, to wipe out the mosquito population and thereby eliminate Zika and Malaria, along with other mosquito carried diseases which do terrible damage to humans worldwide. There are some who regard the extinction of a species as a major moral and ethical conundrum. Others worry about the effect on other species if there were no mosquitos. There are many other species, including some birds and fish, that feed on mosquitos and their larvae. The in turn might become endangered or also extinct.
Greedy was addressing the implications of the rapidly developing biological techniques of pre and in vitro genetic manipulation of cells to produce or inhibit certain characteristics of the human fetus and the human being thereafter who would develop therefrom.