Ashleigh Banfield Quotes
I have had it with people who are threatening me and my kids and my family over simply commenting on the law and criminal procedure, and respecting juries. Because they do work hard. They work way harder than I do; and they work way harder than the rest of those people making those peanut gallery comments.
Banfield, Ashleigh. Legal View with Ashleigh Banfield. CNN, 15 July 2013.
This is a very important and fundamental quotation. Jefferson, John Adams, John Jay and many other Founding Fathers told us that the jury of peers was the final arbiter of a court case. However, many modern judges and legislatures have tried to erode that principle. In most states judges instructs juries that they are the final arbiter of the facts but he/she is the final arbiter of the law and how it should be applied in the case. But the founders wanted the jury to be the final arbiters of the law as well as the facts as is illustrated here and in {640587} and {640589}. For a more modern concurring view, see {640590}.
Ever since that decision was written, lawmakers, judges and attorneys have worked very hard to minimize its impact and allow the jury to only decide on the facts and not the law. Only Maryland today preserves the right of the jury to decide what the law means and to judge it. Authorities, even democratic ones, do all they can to prevent what is called “jury nullification”. Regardless, juries often exercise that right regardless of the judge’s instructions.
Note that in his very definition of a Petty Jury the right of the jury to ignore the judge's instructions in criminal matters wasa assumed--not some novel idea. Jury nullification has been a part of the American Criminal Justice System from the inception of the nation.
Ashleigh Dennistoun Banfield is a Canadian-American journalist and host of Banfield. She is a former host of Legal View with Ashleigh Banfield and Early Start on CNN.