Charles Pinkney Quotes
Divide the Continent into four Divisions, out of which a certain number of persons should be nominated, and out of that nomination to appoint a Senate
Charles Pinkney, 1757-1824, South Carolina Delegate to the Constitutional Convention, Proposed method of selecting the Senate, Quoted in the 1787 notes of Georgia Delegate William Leigh Pierce, ~1740-1789
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
Most legislative bodies have rules about when and under what conditions a vote is taken. Amendments, procedures, committees all have procedures where votes may be taken that could defeat a nomination or a proposed law but if those defeats fail, there still is not necessarily a law passed or a nomination confirmed. That has to be a separate vote, often called an “up or down vote.” One parliamentary mechanism for opposing a bill or a nomination is to keep voting on amendments and procedures and never have an up or down vote. This is actually true with the vast majority of the laws proposed in both houses of the Congress. Most never do have an up or down vote. Why Gerhatdt and other ask should judicial nominations be different from any law, or any other presidential nomination? Also see {588517} for another factor.
The issue of how the federal judiciary would be selected was one of the more hotly debated issues during the Constitutional Convention.