Paul Singer Quotes


Credit ratings and risk weightings must undergo a thorough process of review and revision. No security or instrument on the planet should have a zero risk weighting.


Citations

Singer, Paul. "A Free-Market Alternative to Dodd-Frank." Manhattan Institute, 2012.

Related Quotes

4 years after the Great Recession where major banks of America needed government bailouts to prevent failure the Administration and Federal Reserve board wanted to increase the capital requirements to increase the safety of the Banks. Essentially the banks would speculate and gamble with depositors’ money. If their investment paid off, there were large profits and bonuses for the executives. If it did not, they ran out of capital as they had very little of their own at risk. The government bailed them out and the executives got their bonuses anyway. The efforts to make the banks speculate with more of their own money were strongly opposed by the banks and bank executives.


Moody’s and Standard & Poors, the 2 largest credit rating agencies, gave A ratings to securities that had packaged terrible F-rated, toxic, subprime mortgages, and gotten the credit ratings agencies to rate them as A on the theory that the risk was diversified. Each new security like this that a bank put out was submitted informally to one of the credit rating agencies to “discuss”. If the agency “concluded” that they could give it an A rating, they received a very large fee. If not, the bank would not officially submit the security and not pay anything. That almost never happened with these packages of subprime mortgages.


He was referring to Fannie Mae, the government-created. private mortage guarantee company. It was heavily regulated, and in general it met the regulatory requirements. However, the requirements were insufficient, and in the 2008 Meltdown and the Great Recession that followed, Fannie Mae itself was in such bad financial condition, that the Federal Government had bail them out or have the entire home mortgage industry fall apart.


All three of the credit rating agencies gave securities of bundled very risky mortgages the highest and most secure ratings. They never examined the underlying securities, and continued to give these AAA ratings even after many had defaulted and they were in “junk bond” status. The rules then were that the financial companies who wanted a rating would “discuss” the rating that they would get BEFORE they paid the rating companies to do the rating. In no case did they ever pay a rating agency for a rating unless there would be a AAA rating despite the fact that these securities were among the highest risk public securities in American financial history. Under the law at the time, the rating agencies could not be held liable for there irrational ratings.


Paul Singer
Paul Singer
  • Born: August 22, 1944
  • Nationality: American
  • Profession: Hedge Fund Manager

Paul Elliott Singer is an American hedge fund manager, activist investor, philanthropist, and the founder, president and Co-CEO of Elliott Management.