G. John Ikenberry Quotes
... authoritarian states sign on [to human rights treaties] solely for propaganda purposes and then find it fairly easy to flout the rules.
In some cases, the authoritarian state signed on with a "reservation". Egypt signed with the proviso that nothing is binding if it contradicts Islamic law, and then proceeds to violate many of the most basic of human rights of many of its citizens using the most fundamentalist interpretation of Islamic Law—Sharia. Women's rights are trampled upon via this method. The Government claims that they ae signatories to the treaty and follow it.
G. John Ikenberry, Political Scientist Brookings Institution, Book Review, Foreign Affairs, January / February, 2015
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
The treaty to which he referred was The Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment. During the George W. Bush administration the CIA had tortured 3 captives in the War on Terror. The CIA destroyed the video tapes of the torture sessions and many Americans wanted President Obama to investigate and prosecute the torturers in accordance with the requirements of the treaty when there is a torture incident. However, a major ethical and legal complication was that the Bush Administration had issued an official legal memorandum to the CIA which said that the forms of torture that they used, water boarding, was not legally torture. Most legal scholars agree that this legal opinion was incorrect and America had previously prosecuted and punished the few American soldiers who had used Waterboarding. President Obama decided that since the CIA torturers, had been authorized in writing, that a criminal prosecution would be unfair. He also declined to have the Justice Department investigate the torture incidents, Many disagreed, and this quotation summarized their point of view. See {642428} for some of the language of the Convention.
Gilford John Ikenberry is a theorist of international relations and United States foreign policy, and the Albert G. Milbank Professor of Politics and International Affairs at Princeton University. He is known for his work on liberal International Relations theory, such as the books After Victory (2001) and Liberal Leviathan (2011).