Igor Quotes
And if he be taken in battle ... He shall be returned to his native land, in return for his price
Igor, ~915-*, King of Russia, Treaty with Byzantium on the return of prisoners of war, 944
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
Lieber was assigned by President Lincoln to study the then international laws of war and prepare a manual for the guidance of union troops in the Civil War. Lincoln then issued the document as a general order. This particular article is particularly relevant to the modern war on terrorism where there is criticism of the treatment of captured terrorists. There are some who argue that they should be treated as prisoners of war. However, under the principles of this article, they specifically ought not to be so treated. Incidentally, highway robbers and pirates at the time were hanged.
Most nations, although committed to popular sovereignty, have laws against small sections of their nation deciding to secede and become part of a border nation. Whether or not a small minority of a nation may separate without a total national referendum has been a political dilemma for countries for years. If a larger portion of the country were in the plebiscite, they would have voted to stay in the Ukraine. While most nations agree that people should have the right of self-determination, there is no agreement on what unit of “the people” can decide. In most pluralistic nations, there are always smaller areas whose political views differ from the majority of the country. Should one near a border be allowed to vote to join the border nations? Most nations have said no.
The German Generals talked him out of the idea, but the quotation gives an insight into the Character of the German Leader. It never occurred to him that the Russians might retaliate and murder German prisoners.
The American sailors had been captured and were being held for ransom by the Barbary Pirates in terrible conditions. The pirates stated that they were slaves and would be sold if the United States did not come up with enough ransom money. After much debate in America, a squadron of Naval Troops had been dispatched to the Mediterranean where they would “negotiate” with cannon—attacking the ports of the Barbary States.
The “slaves” were American merchant sailors whose ships had been taken by the Barbary Pirates of Algiers who the Dey controlled. He was actually negotiating and trying to get a high price with this statement. The graphic shows a Barbary pirate ship chasing a merchant galley.
The Barbary Pirates had an incredible extortion racket going in the Mediterranean. If nations would pay them an annual sum each year, they would not attack and seize merchant ships of that country and sell the ships and goods while holding the sailors for ransom.
Two were executed and the others sent to the Gulags. This is often quoted to show how hostile the Soviet Union was to all religions.
The law was against stealing corn from a farm of field, There was a tradition in Russia that no one should be jailed for corn stealing unless he stole 5 or more ears of corn. However, many people repeatedly helped themselves to 4 ears, and the party wanted it stopped. What is fascinating is that his insistence that the law as promulgated by the Party be enforced literally without regard to issues of higher justice such as starvation and necessity, placed him in the same legal posture as the capitalist countries which also insisted that the laws be enforced and not tempered by higher moral issues of fairness. Whoever has the power to make the laws wants them to be enforced literally. Most others want them tempered by issues of justice, fairness, and necessity.
By paying kidnappers who hold Americans hostage for ransom, the United States would just be encouraging the kidnappers and produce more kidnapping. However in some hostage situation, especially with ISIS and other terrorists the refusal to pay ransom means a horrible and cruel death for the American kidnap victims. Many of the European nations tend to secretly pay the hostage takers just as they were will to pay the Barbary Pirates and Corsairs in the 18th century. There is no right answer other than to defeat the terrorists and put them out of business.
She served as the head of the Task Foce that the President asked to come up with better poliocies and procedures for coping with situations were Americans were being held hostage for ransom. The poliocy had been that the United States would not pay meny for hostages and it was a crime for the families and friends to do so. After the report, the government still would not pay terrorists for hostages, but the new policy allowed family and friends to do so if they wanted. A number of Amricans have been murdered when hostage money was not paid. Some argue that the government should pay the ransom lest life and death depend on the wealth of the family of the victim. Most terrorism experts argue against paying at all. In addition to encouraging the terrorists to take more Amercian hostages, the hostage money goes to the terrorists who use it to endanger and kill other Americans. There is no good answer to this situation.
He was explaining his repudiation of General John Fremont’s military proclamation in Missouri confiscating rebel property and emancipating their slaves. See {633732} .