Daniel J. Elazar Quotes


The world's modern constitutions can be classified according to five basic constitutional models: (1) the constitution as frame of government; (2) the constitution as code; (3) the constitution as revolutionary manifesto; (4) the constitution as political ideal; and (5) the constitution as a modern adaptation of an ancient traditional constitution.


Context

Citizen of U. S. & Israel


Citations

Daniel J. Elazar, Political Scientist Secretary of the American Political Science Association, President, Israel Political Science Association, Member, U.S. Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations, Founder and President of the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, Introduction, The Constitution of the State of Israel

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

When President Grover Cleveland balked at introducing legislation that might be unconstitutional, he was asked:


In a 1949 dissenting opinion in Terminiello v. Chicago Jackson claimed the majority view would “convert the Bill of Rights into a suicide pact.”


Most of the states would not ratify the proposed 1787 constitution as it was. Congress then added a version of what became known as the Bill of Rights in order to obtain the required concurrence of the people. Most scholars look at the 1787 Constitution and observe how little trust it had in the men who would rule and implement it. However, the people in general were even more skeptical than the intellectual leaders who drafted the Constitution and wanted even more assurances. Many people believed that most of the issues in the Bill of Rights were either implicit in the original 1787 draft or were unnecessary to spell out, but Congress had to sell the Constitution to the people as a whole and it took some very specific text to get people to believe that their rights would be protected.


The English Constitution is not as binding on the English government as is the Amercan Constitution. In the English system, the government in power can override the constitution although the rarely do so out of respect for the system. In America, the Constitution is much more controlling and hence would be seen to count for more. In many third world countries, the ruler can “suspend” the constitution in a national emergency.


There are many countries that adhere to a rule of law, for which their Constitution is the fundamental document providing a framework for their legal system which is adhered to. A few nations which are strong adherents to the rule of law, but have no constitution; the instead have a very strong system of Common Law which establishes their legal precedents and a legislative tradition of restraint which provides fixed principles (Great Britain and Israel are two good examples). But the biggest problem for many countries in not adhering to the rule of law, is having a written constitution and then ignoring it when making legal decisions for the nation, Balaguer’s quotation here is typical of the attitude which causes nations with fine constitutions to function without any serious adherence to rule of law.


Daniel J. Elazar
Daniel J. Elazar
  • Born: August 25, 1934
  • Died: December 2, 1999
  • Nationality:
  • Profession: Political Scientist

Daniel Judah Elazar was a political scientist known for his seminal studies of political culture of the US states. He was professor of political science at Bar-Ilan University in Israel and Temple University in Pennsylvania, and director of the Center for the Study of Federalism at Temple University and the founder and president of the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs.