Greg Thielmann Quotes
Military intervention for disarmament is the worst possible way to do it. There are times when perhaps that is the only alternative we have… in the case of the first Gulf war -- Desert Storm -- that it was the UN inspectors -- in the years after the war -- that destroyed far more weapons and far more effectively dismantled the programs for weapons of mass destruction, than that vast armada of military forces that was utilized in Desert Storm. And of course, when the UN inspectors did it -- when under UN supervision, the Iraqis destroyed these weapons themselves -- or the UN destroyed them with Iraqi cooperation -- you do not have the same kind of side effects and toxic release and other things that happened in some cases during the war. Trying to get rid of programs of concern and weapons of concern by violence is a very bad and dangerous way to do it.
While Thielmann’s observations were accurate, what he did not say was that many critics argue that it is not very likely that the Iraqi’s would have allowed the United Nations inspectors to destroy their weapons unless there had been a major military defeat of the Iraqi military forces first.
Greg Thielmann, Director of Strategic, Proliferation and Military Affairs Office, Intelligence Bureau, U. S. State Department's, Interview, July 27th, 2004
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
This early call for arms control was little heeded. Note his recommendation that governments which do not adhere to arms control agreements be replaced—regime change. The George Biush administration could have used this quotation in promoting their regime change policy in the Iraq War.
As a member of NATO, the Prime Minister was given the same faulty intelligence that the Bush Administration gave to Congress, our allies and gave to Colin Powell to brief the United Nations. All were similarly misled. There were no WMDs in Iraq and Iraq did not even have an active program to develop them.
See {633152} for more of the reasoning for this point. “Neocon” is a shortened form of “neoconservative”. At the time the neoconservatives were advocating use of military intervention in the Middle East. Munich was the German city in which British Prime Minister notoriously tried to appease Hitler and the Nazis. This led to WWII and has become the historical icon for appeasement of a powerful tyrant and the cost of such.
As the atomic bomb evolved to the hydrogen bomb and the test results were learned by political and military leaders, the perception of the danger became much greater, especially when the Russians and French also developed their nuclear weapons. After that, and Einstein’s predictions about the cost and quantity, leaders in the world all became conscious of the danger of Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD), most leaders realized that it was impossible see atomic weapons as anything but defense.
1st Earl Baldwin of Bewdley. Baldwin has been castigated since WWII for being part of the “appeasement group” in England. As Prime Minister in 1935 he would not face the threat of Fascism, Germany and the Nazis and did not initiate a major arms buildup. Churchill, among others, never forgave him. See {626930} for Churchill’s view of Baldwin.
A. Gregory Thielmann is a former mid-level official in the U.S. State Department's Bureau of Intelligence and Research who, after retiring in September 2002, publicly disputed the rationale for the U.S. invasion of Iraq offered by the George W. Bush administration. He is currently a board member of the Arms Control Association and member of the Council on Foreign Relations. His areas of expertise and research include threat assessments, nuclear/missile proliferation, and US-Russian strategic arms control.