Lisa McGirr Quotes
It seems paradoxical that a region so dependant on the Federal government decried government influence.
Lisa McGirr, Historian, Comment on the Conservatives of Orange County, California, a bastion of the radical right, yet an area which gets enormous federal assistance of various forms, Suburban Warriors: The Origins of the New American Right, 2003
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
His reference was to his experience as an undergraduate at Dartmouth, which he and associates views as a liberal organization, while others viewed it as a conservative bastion of the establishment.
The Tea Party Republican faction was opposed to government doing much of anything other than Defense and Foreign Policy. The regular Republicans saw a much more extensive and robust role of government though few did so to the same extent as Abraham Lincoln and the other founders of the Republican Party, and Theodore Roosevelt and Dwight D. Eisenhower the Republicans following in the Alexander Hamilton tradition.
England did not follow this precept but the United States did and is the only country that did. In all others, education is controlled by the national government. However, Godwin's principle of separating education from government is not maintained in all the states of America. In many, the State government leaves much of the curriculum and the operations of the school to local school boards which have a great deal of discretion. However, in most of the Southern States, the State government dominates and controls education and relatively little is left to the school boards. In some the State chooses the allowable textbooks. In those cases, Godwin's principle is violated, but in most of the North East and Midwest and some of the far West the school boards have great autonomy and Goodwin's principle is upheld. It is fascinating that the more control a particular state exercises of the schools, the poorer the performance of the schools of that state. Goodwin had a terrific insight.
What if you are a conservative in a liberal environment? Then what you are conserving is liberalism.
His reference was to his experience as an undergraduate at Dartmouth, which he and associates views as a liberal organization, while others viewed it as a conservative bastion of the establishment.
Goldwater was the Republican Nominee for President and Kilpatrick a Journalist & Columnist. Both were leading conservatives of their time.
There are many who think his points apply equally well to America.
The Republicans in the previous decades had gone so far to the right and were so opposed to anything the government might do, that they could not support anything that might be constructive for the country if it might look like the Government was capable of something positive. They accomplished almost nothing as a result, and the nation was gridlocked.
Not only did the people in Afghanistan have very little experience with central government, but they had little history of government of any sort. There were loose tribes somewhat unified by culture, but there was little or no tribal government. The same with clans. Each Afghanistan male was his own ruler over his wives and children in a family centric society. While virtually all were Muslim, there was no hierarchy or structure of the clergy in that society.
To conservatives of the day the notion of an SEC or Interstate Commerce Commission or anti-Trust legislation or any kind of Federal interference with a private corporation was basic communism and unheard of. It is hard for us today to understand how radical an idea it was that the Federal Government should inspect food to make sure that it was safe or that a company might be restricted from putting all its competitors out of business with predatory pricing and then when there was no competition left charging outrageous prices and gouge the public. Even the notion of saying that a company could not lie about their products in order to sell them more effectively was radical.