Joan Robinson Quotes
It is the rate of investment which governs the rate of saving, and not vice versa.
Robinson, Joan. Introduction to the Theory of Employment. Macmillan, 1937, p. 14.
Mises defines government revenue in such a manner that it always relly belonged to individuals, therefore when government invests in enterprises that accumulate capital via profits, Mises does not consider it capital accumulation. One counterexample of this point is the George Washington Bridge in New York, built in Mises lifetime by Robert Moses of the New York Port Authority. The tolls on the bridge paid off the bondholders who financed much of the initial construction. But then capital started to accumulate at such a rapid rate that Moses was able to build other capital projects ranging from highways to the World Trade Center Buildings with capital constantly accumulated. The New York Port Authority under Moses generated more capital appreciation than any corporation that had been in existence at that point. And he could not even sell stock. However, the Port Authority and a few others were exceptions. Generally government did was unable to accumulate capital in its enterprises.
This is the equivalent of “if you build it, they will come.” This is one of those so called “Law” of economics that is really not always so. In many cases it holds, as when Disney Built Disney World or Apple issued the iPhone. However, it clearly does not hold when there is a surplus of a commodity.
Joan Violet Robinson FBA was a British economist well known for her wide-ranging contributions to economic theory. She was a central figure in what became known as post-Keynesian economics.