Ethel M. Elderton Quotes
Improvement in social conditions will not compensate for a bad hereditary influence.
She was one of Francis Galton’s collaborators in his laboratory. This particular quotation if true challenges some of the basic aspects of democracy itself. However, it was a large part of the basis for the Eugenics movement, and is still argued by some today.
Ethel M. Elderton, 1878–1954, British Eugenicist & Statistician, The Relative Strength Of Nurture And Nature
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
This quotation is important for two reasons. First, it appears to be the first use of the nature-nurture words to discuss this concept. Second, this “conclusion” started one of the longest running scientific debates in biology—nurture vs nature.
He was the intellectual antithesis of Francis Galton and the Eugenicists in the Nature vs Nurture debates.
His argument is that the children of the wealthy tend to become rich, not by inheriting money from their parents but by culturally and educationally becoming assimilated to and skilled at the language and norms of business and capitalism. There is a great deal of evidence to support this, however there is a political split between those who argue that inheritance taxes will do little or no good in producing equal opportunity for children of wealthy and poor parents. Therefore, abolish the tax. Others argue that the tax is needed to make up for the differential capability at money making as the funds could be used to provide better training for the children of the poor.
There were some people at the time who believed that by means of effort and following moral precepts there would be an equality of achievement. There were also many who began to observe that much of the differences between individuals were are result of environment—opportunity for education, socialization and other factors. Science is still trying to determine the relative causal contributions to individual differences of genetics and environment.
Peel himself was a large land owner. Many Conservatives thought Peel was a traitor to his party and socio economic class just as many Republicans thought Theodore Roosevelt such a “traitor to his class” for not maintaining the privileges of the rich. By 2012, Conservatives who did not support the rich were vilified as “not conservatives” and “socialists.”
Though a great early science, he was ignorant of the many non-genetic factors that could cause deformities in children ranging from nutritional deficiency to improper delivery techniques. Even in the genetic area he had no inkling of mutations where deformities develop and have NOTHING to do with either parent’s genetic history. Last, he did not realize that a large proportion of all pregnancies abort before the mother even realizes that she was pregnant.
At the time, many scientists and intellectuals thought erroneously—see related quotations—that hybrids would be inferior humans. What makes this quotation memorable is that although he acknowledged that empirically, mixed race people (human hybrids) were inferior, of offered an explanation that did not violate sound genetic science as most others did. He concluded that sociologically whites and black who would intermarry or interbreed would generally not come from the top echelons of either race. Therefore the lower half of each race would more likely produce offspring and provide them with an environment that was not optimum so genetics and nurture worked against the mulatto. At the time that may well have been so, and perhaps until recently it was so forth the majority of crossbreeds of many societies.
Ethel Mary Elderton (1878–1954) was a British eugenics researcher who worked with Francis Galton and Karl Pearson.