Daniel Dennett Quotes


If I were designing a phony religion, I'd surely include a version of this little gem -- but I'd have a hard time saying it with a straight face:, If anybody ever raises questions of objections about our religion that you cannot answer, that person is almost certainly Satan. In fact, the more reasonable the person is, the more eager to engage you in open-minded and congenial discussion, the more sure you can be that you're talking to Satan in disguise! Turn away! Do not listen! It's a trap!, What is particularly cute about this trick is that it is a perfect "wild card," so lacking in content that any sect or creed or conspiracy can use it effectively. Communist cells can be warned that any criticism they encounter is almost sure to be the work of FBI infiltrators in disguise, and radical feminist discussion groups can squelch any unanswerable criticism by declaring it to be phallocentric propaganda being unwittingly spread by a brainwashed dupe of the evil patriarchy, and so forth. This all-purpose loyalty-enforcer is paranoia in a pill, sure to keep the critics muted if not silent.


Citations

Daniel Dennett, Philosopher, Breaking the Spell: Religion As A Natural Phenomenon, 2006

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

Surprising to most people who know of President Theodore Roosevelt’s general liberal views, his 4th son was an ultraconservative who founded and joined racist, anti-Semitic, right wing organizations, and to the distress of many in the family and without lent his name to many of the most extreme right wing causes and organizations.


He lists a number of employees including his own wife. The foundation was the L. Ron Hubbard Dianetic Research Foundation Inc. In this case a religious leader was asking the government for assistance in determining who was and was not fit to be a member and an associate of his organization. The FBI apparently ignored his accusations, and there was no government action though he continued to accuse associates throughout his life. The FBI agent who met with Hubbard to investigate his charges wrote “mental case” on the file.


Lyford was convinced that the Satanists had killed and eaten many children. The eaten children had been missing and were not found and since they had been eaten there was no evidence of the deaths. Texas has had more than its share of prosecutors who have very loose legal standards, but this was exteme, even in Texas, Incredibly enough some people were almost convicted of murder in this modern version of a witch hunt with the same logic that the lack of evidence proved Satan was behind it as only he could cover up all that evidence. Fortunately the Texas Attorney General dismissed Lyford and exonerated the suspects.


This quotation is often used to illustrate the complete intellectual conformity that was (and for some still is) required of the Roman Catholic Church. Although this was a theological statement, it is sometimes functionally used as a definition of loyalty to a President or other political figure with respect to staff.


Daniel Dennett
Daniel Dennett
  • Born: March 28, 1942
  • Died: April 19, 2024
  • Nationality: American
  • Profession: Philosopher

Daniel Clement Dennett III is an American philosopher, writer, and cognitive scientist whose research centers on the philosophy of mind, philosophy of science, and philosophy of biology, particularly as those fields relate to evolutionary biology and cognitive science.