Erin Scharff Quotes
Almost one-third of taxpayers earning between $200,000 and $500,000 will pay the AMT, and about 62 percent of those earning between $500,000 and $1 million will. Thanks to the deductions it targets (which make a bigger difference for the next-highest brackets), only one-fifth of those earning more than $1 million pay the AMT. For its disproportionate effect on the well-off rather than the fabulously rich, a truly full-throated defense of the AMT is impossible. Yet for all its flaws and all its enemies, the AMT also solves a real problem. It prevents wealthy and well-advised loophole-seekers from finding ways to evade taxes altogether. It ensures that some people who write off large losses still contribute their share to the national treasury. In 2005, the AMT forced the Trumps, a tremendously rich family, to pay a substantial amount in taxes. Ultimately, the reason the AMT plagues the upper middle class is that the regular taxes imposed on them are historically low. Proposed income tax cuts would only exacerbate this problem. That’s why repealing the AMT is so difficult. Until we can reform our regular tax code in ways that more equitably raise revenue, it’s also what makes repealing the AMT a bad idea.
The AMT is the alternate minmum tax law which provides a monimum tax the upper middle class and moderately wealthy must pay even if they find enough loopholes and tax deductions to reduce their tax to nothing or almoist nothing. It did not rally significantly affect the taxes of the 1 percent and superrich taxpayers who still were able to avoid most taxes, Originally, it was not targted at the upper middle class, but inflation pushed them into the barackets where they were covered.
Erin Scharff, "The bipartisan boogeyman that makes the rich pay their share". The Washington Post, March 19, 2017
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
As a result of years of lobbying many vested interests were getting tax exemptions for their activities. Some of the richest corporations and people paid little or no taxes. This was like the old European monarchies where the dukes and nobles got tax exemptions from the king and the middle class and poor people paid a much larger percentage of their income and wealth than did the nobility. Fairness in taxation is very difficult in practice. See {633629}
Reacting to proposals to reduce the capital gains tax:
At the time, he, th richest man in America was paying a lower ta rate than his secretary, his employees and the waiter who served him lunch. The “Buffet Rule” was developed and named for him that said that wealthy people should pay a minimum rate of taxation regardless of tax credits, deductions and other means of tax avoidance.
The nation rejected the flat tax that was favored by conservatives in the 1930s. However, in the Republican Presidential Primary Campaign of 2000, candidate Steve Forbes made the flat tax a centerpoint of his campaign. He lost badly, but the idea caught on amongst some conservative Republicans, and has had some support since.
This was a typical argument in the 2012 battle between President Obama and the Republican conservatives. However, this was written 35 years earlier, when the exact same issue was polarizing politicians. The idea for taxing the rich more to reduce the deficit has been around since there was a Federal deficit. On most occasions the rich had enough political clout to avoid additional taxes for them and get the general public to pay instead of them. However, there have been times where they have not been able to avoid increased taxes. The New Deal lead by Franklin Delano Roosevelt and the Obama administration in 2013 were two such exceptions.
His minimum tax proposal was for the income over $10 million was 35%. For income between $1 million and $10 million, it was 30%. At the time, he found that his secretary, everyone who worked in his office, and the waiter who served him lunch, all paid a higher income tax rate than he did. President Obama, in a great struggle with the Republicans who fought to retain the lower tax rates for the wealthy with deductions, was able to terminate the Bush tax cuts for the very rich.
The last tax reform before this quotation was made was in 1986. The iphone was not launched untanchin wasil 2007. There were actuallt some crude mobile phones available in 1986, but they were far from our concept of a cell thone today, None of these early attempts were successful economically or technologically.
Even on Medieval days in Europe, the wealthy barons paid lower tax rates that their lowest peasants. Relief from taxes was one of the privileges of the very rich. The practice has been made more cosmetic, but the result seems to have been the same into the 21st century.
Erin Adele Scharff writes about tax policy and tax federalism. Prior to joining the faculty, Professor Scharff was an Acting Assistant Professor of Tax Law at New York University School of Law. After graduating magna cum laude from New York University School of Law, she clerked for the Honorable William A. Fletcher of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in San Francisco. In law school, she was a Root-Tilden-Kern Scholar, a Furman Academic Scholar, and an articles editor for the NYU Law Review.