Ken Lieberthal Quotes
The Chinese are engaging in a huge amount of cyber-espionage… So do we…. We can’t ask the Chinese to stop doing something that we’re doing. We can’t ask them to obey rules that we don’t ask France and others to obey…. I think it’s going to take a while even to figure out even the rules we would like everyone to adhere to that we are prepared to adhere to ourselves.
At the time this quotation was created, the Chinese hacking had done no harm in the sense that they did not destroy the data in any of our computers or render some computers non-operational. We actually had done that and more – using hacking to affect destroy part of an Iranian nuclear fuel processing facility, but we had never done that to China, nor had China to us. A difference that outraged some Americans is that they viewed it as “fair game” to do espionage on military and political secrets. The Chinese however, in addition to that, did much industrial spying on American commercial innovations and manufacturing techniques. The French and the South Koreans, however, had been doing this for years, and American politicians were careful not to make a public issue about it and try to minimize it with diplomacy. However, all this makes a solution hard to come by as Liebenthal explained in his quotation.
Ken Lieberthal, Member, National Security Council, PBS News Hour, March 14, 2013
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
Many people not only disagreed with him but thought is analogy was also wrong. Most of the nations in the world do not have a navy. The few that do, have never claimed that the navy was deployed for civilian purposes. They did so to protect their merchant ships, prevent blockades and to project power—all military activities. Critics observe that few nations would risk a situation where their enemies might cyberattack them and they would have no defenses and could not counterattack. So other nations will respond to large cyberdefenses deployed by some countries with an “arms race” of cyberdefense. The reason the United States added 4000 personnel to Cyber Command was because China and Russia had deployed cyberdefense capability. Also cyberdefense capability produces cyberattack capability. These critics argue that cyberspace is already militarized.
A number of the hacking incidents that occurred in 2016 were done by foreign governments. This was a subtle form of threatening those nations who had been doing the hacking of American public and private entities. Without making any overt threat to retaliate, he was reminding would be future hackers to desist less the U. S. decide to retaliate in kind with greater capacity and more sophisticated techniques.