William T. Sali Quotes


Obviously I would hope that women would be discouraged from having abortions if they know that there's an increased risk, but clearly if we care about women we should want them to know about this elevated risk. What's the damage of women being told some people think there's a link between abortion and breast cancer? What does that hurt? ... All I've said is that studies show that there is a statistical link between abortion and breast cancer, an increased risk, and women before they have an abortion should be told.


Context

This quotation illustrates what often happens with very controversial issues in politics. The Congressman was concerned that a woman should not choose to have an abortion without knowing of the facts about the risks to her health or life. And it is very difficult to argue with his view under normal circumstances. However, in this particular case, the fact is not a fact at all. There is no relationship between breast cancer and abortions. There are many people who do not view abortion as a health issue but as a religious/moral issue. As such, they start with a position that everything should be done to minimize abortion. When someone speculates that there is a link between abortion and breast cancer, they are all too willing to accept the relationship. The Congressman admitted that he did not personally know about any research proving the link, but he argued that he had been told this, believed it in good faith, and therefore wanted to legislate a requirement to so inform women contemplating abortion. However, his opponents on this issue pointed out that a two minute search of the Internet would have easily found that both the U.S. National Cancer Institute and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists reviewed the possible relationship in 2003 and published their conclusions that there's no link between abortion and breast cancer. Also that The International Journal of Cancer published similar findings based on a study of women in nine countries. The idea of warning women about the risks of abortion as a legal requirement is all the more problematical in that the risk of an abortion in the United States today is LESS than the risk of giving birth to a child. The risk is very low, but in America about 10 women out of every 100,000 who give birth will die of complications of one kind or another. Fewer die for every 100,000 abortions. Both numbers used to be much higher but medical improvements and the legalization of abortion has made both procedures safer.


Citations

William T. Sali, U. S. Congressman (Republican, ID), Quoted in Betsy Z. Russell, Anger trails Sali cancer comments, October 31, 2006, http://www.spokesmanreview.com/tools/story_pf.asp?ID=157294

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

There is a very slight risk to the woman with a modern abortion procedure. There is a much greater risk to a woman who chooses to bring the fetus to term and give birth. The risk is small but it is 14 times more risk of maternal mortality (death to the mother) than with an abortion. There is also a much higher proportion of mental health problems (eg Post Partum Psychosis) for women who give birth. Most anti abortion advocates argue the issue on moral grounds and their view that we have a moral obligation not to take life. This has great legitimacy and there is a very large minority of Americans who agree with this position. However, anti-abortion advocates like Fortenberry who either are ignorant of the medical science and statistics or knows but lies about it, harm the cause they advocate for by coming across to many Americans as ignorant and/or untruthful, and they discredit the many fair and honest abortion foes.


History has shown that as girls and women get educated and learn about family planning, their children are healthier and have better chances of survival and despite the lower death rate the population trend slows as a result of family planning.


On this medical statement she was contradicted by the FDA, National Institutes of Health, the CDC, the AMA and every Obstetrical organization and association.


The argument she made is that a woman should not be required to risk her life if she does not want to. Other than military conscription, there is no other aspect of American law whereby the society forces a citizen to risk their life.


William T. Sali
William T. Sali
  • Born: February 17, 1954
  • Nationality:
  • Profession: Attorney

William Thomas Sali is an American politician who served as a congressman from Idaho. A Republican, he served a single term in the United States House of Representatives, representing Idaho's 1st congressional district from 2007 to 2009. Sali previously served in the Idaho Legislature as a member of the House.